Last week we took a look at the Bombino Bianco grape and noted that one of its synonyms was Pagadebit, or "debt-payer." In that post, I alluded to a grape grown in the Emilia-Romagna region of Italy that is also known as Pagadebit and is thought to be the same as Bombino Bianco. It turns out that most of what is known as Pagadebit in Emilia-Romagna may actually be Bombino, but some of it is actually a rarer, much less well-known grape called Mostosa, which is what we'll be taking a look at today.
Figuring out exactly what Mostosa is isn't an easy task. Most sources, if they mention the grape at all, only mention that it is a rare white grape used primarily for blending in the Lazio and southern Emilia-Romagna regions of Italy. Some sources also indicate that Mostosa may be the same as the Biancone grape, and it is here, in the area of accepted synonyms for the grape, that the trouble really starts. All grapes that are grown anywhere in the world have several different names that they are known by, generally as a result of their movement through different regions (Chasselas, for example, has over 200 synonyms). Before the days of the internet and the world-wide wine scene, grape growers from different regions weren't necessarily in very close contact with one another, so as new grapes arrived and settled in, they tended to pick up names from the local dialect or they picked up colorful descriptive names that the local farmers may have just liked more than whatever the grape had been called when it first arrived. In Europe especially, the names of the grapes weren't that important because the wines were (and for the most part still are) labeled geographically and not varietally, so as long as a vine grew well and made decent wine, it wasn't really all that important what you called it or, to some extent, even what it was. In many countries, Appellation Control laws have changed that by specifying the specific grape types that can be grown in a given region, but remember that these laws are less than 100 years old, while the history of grape growing and wine making goes back thousands of years.
It is also important to note that since there was no centralized place for information about what a vine actually was, mistakes were often made either by growers or people selling vines either due to mislabeling or misidentification both of the accidental and of the malicious sort. When vines are very young, they all look pretty much the same. Even when they grow up, it takes a skilled eye to differentiate between the thousands of different grape types, and mistakes often happened. There is the famous story about how most of what was grown in Chile and called Merlot actually turned out to be Carmenere. As information about grapes becomes more centralized, and as genetic testing becomes more sophisticated and accessible, it is becoming easier to correct these mistakes and to figure out exactly what is going on in many of these vineyards.
With today's grape, I suspect that the issue is more with the local naming of grapes than with a case of pure mistaken identity from mislabeled vines. In my opinion, it is the colloquial "Pagadebit" name that is the source of all of the confusion. According to the VIVC, there are four different Italian grapes that have Pagadebit (or some variation) as an accepted synonym (and one Croatian grape, Plavac Mali). Those four grapes are Pagadebito, Bombino Bianco, Mostosa and Biancone. Of those four, Biancone is an accepted synonym for Mostosa, but not the other way around, while Pagadebito has both Mostosa and Biancone as accepted synonyms. Bombino fits in because it has Pagadebit as an accepted synonym, but is not itself an accepted synonym for any of the other three grapes. All four of the grapes mentioned above have their own VIVC variety numbers, which I believe means that they are distinct cultivars (parent information is only available for Pagadebito and Mostosa, which have different parents and are thus clearly different grapes). Further, Nicolas Belfrage, in his Brunello to Zibibbo, quotes Salvatore del Gaudio and Domenico Giusto's Principali Vitigni as saying: "the descriptions of Trebbiano Abruzzese, of Caccio (another name for Mostosa), and of Pagadebito (almost certainly Bombino Bianco in this context)...differentiate themselves from one another in several respects, so that in the last analysis it seems possible definitely to state that the three are different varieties." There is no mention of Biancone in this analysis, so it's hard to say what their opinion of its relation to Mostosa is. It is worth mentioning, though, that in their Wine Grape Varieties, George Kerridge and A.J. Antcliff note that Biancone is native to Corsica, indicating that it probably isn't related to any of the grapes mentioned above. Further, they note that it is the highest yielding vine currently planted in Australia, clearly showing how it earned its "Pagadebiti" nickname in Corsica.
What I think may have happened is that the Pagadebit name was attached to one of the grapes and then was either picked up by other growers in other regions who decided that the name was an apt descriptor of grapes they were growing. It is certainly possible that the growers in each different region came up with the name independently of one another, but it seems unlikely. I imagine that a grower traveling into a different region may have heard the locals refer to one of their grapes with that name and thought to himself, "I have a vine just like that back home," and may have started referring to his own crop with that name. Over time, the name got entrenched and when people scan the vinous landscape today, they want to believe that grapes that share synonyms are related in some way, possibly even identical. I don't believe that these grapes are related any more than I believe that all people with the last name Smith are related, though I would be very interested to see someone do the DNA analysis to see what the story really is.
All of that colloquialism is well and good, but we live in an official world and when we are dealing with wine that crosses international borders, some arm of officialdom inevitably steps in. My journey down this road began when I picked up a bottle of the 2010 Trere Pagadebit di Romagna frizzante from my friends at the Wine Bottega for about $12. The wine is from the Pagadebit di Romagna DOC, which requires a minimum of 85% Bombino Bianco. The back label on the bottle, however, indicated that this wine is made from 85% Mostosa and 15% Chardonnay grapes. I emailed the winery to ask whether Mostosa and Bombino were the same grape or, if not, how they were able to bottle a DOC wine from Mostosa grapes, but received no response. Their website also clearly indicates that Mostosa is the primary grape here, as does the Wine Bottega's site, and the research that I've done seems to indicate that Bombino and Mostosa are definitely two distinct grapes. I'm not sure what's going on with all the official stuff, but it's really between Trere and the Italian government, I suppose.
In the glass, this wine was a pale greenish silvery lemon color with a little fizz to it. The nose was nicely aromatic with candied green apple (or sour apple candy or something like that) and a touch of flowers. On the palate the wine was on the lighter side of medium with medium acidity and a light, fizzy texture. It was somewhere between dry and off-dry with flavors of candied green apple, a touch of apricot/stone fruit and just a little bit of toastiness. There was also a distinctive apple peel character that almost verged on cider. Overall, the wine was light and fruit and very similar to Prosecco, though a little less bubbly and slightly more complex. It's a fun little wine that's very enjoyable for the money and is probably best on its own or with light snacks.
A blog devoted to exploring wines made from unusual grape varieties and/or grown in unfamiliar regions all over the world. All wines are purchased by me from shops in the Boston metro area or directly from wineries that I have visited. If a reviewed bottle is a free sample, that fact is acknowledged prior to the bottle's review. I do not receive any compensation from any of the wineries, wine shops or companies that I mention on the blog.
Monday, November 21, 2011
Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Bombino Bianco - Puglia, Italy
Today's grape has one of my very favorite grape names of all time. Bombino Bianco is so fun to say and makes me picture these little white bombs growing on grapevines. Sadly (for me anyway) the name has nothing to do with bombs, but exactly where it comes from isn't totally clear. One story has it that the grape bunches look a child with its arms outstretched, so the name Bombino comes from the word Bambino, meaning baby. It would take a Herculean effort of imagination to picture a baby with arms outstretched in any of the images for Bombino that I've seen, so I'm extremely dubious about this particular story.
There is a slightly more believable story that relies on the grape's purported heritage for its explanatory power. It thought that the grape may have come over from Spain, though no one offers any evidence (ampelographical or genetic) that I can find to support this hypothesis, and I'm not aware of any vine currently planted in Spain that may be Bombino in disguise. In any case, the story goes that the Spanish name for the grape was Bonvino (meaning "good wine"), but since the Spanish "v" is pronounced like the Italian "b," the name got corrupted to Bombino once it took hold in Italy. This story is convincing only to the extent that you buy that the grape is from Spain, and I find myself wondering if perhaps this origin story was concocted because of its linguistic convenience and is itself ultimately the source for the purported Spanish connection.
Wherever the name's origins truly lie, the grape is today known as Bombino Bianco, except when it isn't. Bombino has a wide variety of synonyms, and these synonyms get us into trouble as we move from region to region within Italy. The grape is known as Pagadebit or Pagadebito in some places, but this is a relatively common synonym for many different grape. The name means "debt-payer" and is commonly used for several grapes that give very high yields and produce a lot of juice for the grower. In particular, there is a grape in Emilia-Romagna known as Pagadebit that was (and, for the most part still is) thought to be the same as Bombino, and a lot of it may be Bombino, but at least some of it is another grape altogether (see my post on Mostosa for info on this grape and on the Pagadebit name more generally). Some sources also indicate that Bombino and Trebbiano d'Abruzzo are one and the same grape, though this also may turn out to be untrue. While Wikipedia lists Trebbiano d'Abruzzo as an accepted synonym for Bombino Bianco, The Oxford Companion to wine indicates that they are distinct grapes, and Nicolas Belfrage, in his Brunello to Zibibbo concurs. Belfrage quotes two Italian writers, Salvatore del Gaudio and Domenico Giusto, who, in their Principali Vitigni, examined the ampelographical characteristics of the two vines and concluded unequivocally that the two grapes are distinct.
So our current situation is essentially this: we find ourselves in Puglia with a grape called Bombino Bianco, which is sometimes called Pagadebit, but which is different from the Pagadebit in Emilia-Romagna, or is at least different from some of the grapes called Pagadebit there, and which was also thought to be identical to Trebbiano d'Abruzzo, but is not. Our Bombino is, as the Pagadebit synonym (and the more colorful Stracchia Cambiale synonym, meaning "tear up the invoices") suggests, a cash crop, grown primarily because it yields explosively and reliably. Few producers bother with bottling the wine, and a great deal of it is shipped to Germany, where it is bottled as ordinary, anonymous EU Table Wine. Nicolas Belfrage's assessment of the potential quality of the grape is summed up when he says "Bombino Bianco can make as dull and tasteless a wine as you could hope to find." He mentions that some producers are experimenting with lower yields in an effort to coax some character from the grape, but ultimately says the wines produced even from these estates are "more for the drinker than the thinker."
Despite that lackluster endorsement, I picked up a bottle of the 2009 Cantele "Telero" Bombino Bianco from my friends at Curtis Liquors for about $8. In the glass, the wine was a pale silvery greenish lemon color. The nose was moderately aromatic with crisp apple, pear, and grapefruit peel aromas. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with medium acidity. There were flavors of pear and lemon with a grapefruit/lemon citrus peel sort of thing lurking in the background. There was something vaguely floral about it, but it wasn't really strong enough to pin down to anything more specific than that. It finished with a chalky kind of minerality that I wasn't particularly crazy about. Overall, it was pretty generic, though I wouldn't go so far as to say it was the most dull or tasteless wine I've ever had. There's nothing here to offend anyone unless you're offended by mediocrity. I will say that if you open this bottle, finish it the same day as it went sharply downhill on day two and became nearly undrinkable. For people who are fans of inexpensive, mild white wines, there's probably a lot here to enjoy. It could sub in very well for some of the high volume Pinot Grigio or Garganega based wines made in northern Italy so if you just feel like switching it up a little bit geographically, give this a shot.
There is a slightly more believable story that relies on the grape's purported heritage for its explanatory power. It thought that the grape may have come over from Spain, though no one offers any evidence (ampelographical or genetic) that I can find to support this hypothesis, and I'm not aware of any vine currently planted in Spain that may be Bombino in disguise. In any case, the story goes that the Spanish name for the grape was Bonvino (meaning "good wine"), but since the Spanish "v" is pronounced like the Italian "b," the name got corrupted to Bombino once it took hold in Italy. This story is convincing only to the extent that you buy that the grape is from Spain, and I find myself wondering if perhaps this origin story was concocted because of its linguistic convenience and is itself ultimately the source for the purported Spanish connection.
Wherever the name's origins truly lie, the grape is today known as Bombino Bianco, except when it isn't. Bombino has a wide variety of synonyms, and these synonyms get us into trouble as we move from region to region within Italy. The grape is known as Pagadebit or Pagadebito in some places, but this is a relatively common synonym for many different grape. The name means "debt-payer" and is commonly used for several grapes that give very high yields and produce a lot of juice for the grower. In particular, there is a grape in Emilia-Romagna known as Pagadebit that was (and, for the most part still is) thought to be the same as Bombino, and a lot of it may be Bombino, but at least some of it is another grape altogether (see my post on Mostosa for info on this grape and on the Pagadebit name more generally). Some sources also indicate that Bombino and Trebbiano d'Abruzzo are one and the same grape, though this also may turn out to be untrue. While Wikipedia lists Trebbiano d'Abruzzo as an accepted synonym for Bombino Bianco, The Oxford Companion to wine indicates that they are distinct grapes, and Nicolas Belfrage, in his Brunello to Zibibbo concurs. Belfrage quotes two Italian writers, Salvatore del Gaudio and Domenico Giusto, who, in their Principali Vitigni, examined the ampelographical characteristics of the two vines and concluded unequivocally that the two grapes are distinct.
So our current situation is essentially this: we find ourselves in Puglia with a grape called Bombino Bianco, which is sometimes called Pagadebit, but which is different from the Pagadebit in Emilia-Romagna, or is at least different from some of the grapes called Pagadebit there, and which was also thought to be identical to Trebbiano d'Abruzzo, but is not. Our Bombino is, as the Pagadebit synonym (and the more colorful Stracchia Cambiale synonym, meaning "tear up the invoices") suggests, a cash crop, grown primarily because it yields explosively and reliably. Few producers bother with bottling the wine, and a great deal of it is shipped to Germany, where it is bottled as ordinary, anonymous EU Table Wine. Nicolas Belfrage's assessment of the potential quality of the grape is summed up when he says "Bombino Bianco can make as dull and tasteless a wine as you could hope to find." He mentions that some producers are experimenting with lower yields in an effort to coax some character from the grape, but ultimately says the wines produced even from these estates are "more for the drinker than the thinker."
Despite that lackluster endorsement, I picked up a bottle of the 2009 Cantele "Telero" Bombino Bianco from my friends at Curtis Liquors for about $8. In the glass, the wine was a pale silvery greenish lemon color. The nose was moderately aromatic with crisp apple, pear, and grapefruit peel aromas. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with medium acidity. There were flavors of pear and lemon with a grapefruit/lemon citrus peel sort of thing lurking in the background. There was something vaguely floral about it, but it wasn't really strong enough to pin down to anything more specific than that. It finished with a chalky kind of minerality that I wasn't particularly crazy about. Overall, it was pretty generic, though I wouldn't go so far as to say it was the most dull or tasteless wine I've ever had. There's nothing here to offend anyone unless you're offended by mediocrity. I will say that if you open this bottle, finish it the same day as it went sharply downhill on day two and became nearly undrinkable. For people who are fans of inexpensive, mild white wines, there's probably a lot here to enjoy. It could sub in very well for some of the high volume Pinot Grigio or Garganega based wines made in northern Italy so if you just feel like switching it up a little bit geographically, give this a shot.
Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Abbuoto (Cecubo) - Campania, Italy
Believe it or not, at one time in history the Abbuoto grape and the wine made from it (Cecubo in Italian, but Caecubum in Latin) were very famous. The Roman poet Horace mentions the wine several times throughout his work, usually as a wine used in grand celebrations, such as Octavius Caesar's victory over Antony and Cleopatra, where Horace described it as "the Caecubum reserved for festal entertainments." The wine was so famous and well thought of that the region where it was produced (today's southern Lazio and northern Campania) was referred to as the Caecuban countryside.
That was a very long time ago, though, and seemingly no wine can resist the force of changing tastes and political turmoil. The Romans began to favor lighter wines and the dense, rich Cecubo began to fall out of favor. Our old friend Pliny blames the downfall of Caecubum on Nero. According to Pliny, the grape was grown in the marshy areas near the Gulf of Amyclae. He believes that its eradication was caused by the "carelessness of the cultivator," whatever that means, and by the building of a canal from Lake Avernus to Ostia by Emperor Nero. The only canal that I can find any evidence that Nero had anything to do with was the Corinth Canal, which was in Greece, so one wonders about the veracity of Pliny's account here. In fact, it seems as though the Roman General Agrippa actually built the canal a few decades before Nero came to power. Many Roman writers were overtly antagonistic to Nero in their texts, so it's totally possible that Pliny is just piling on him at this point. What actually happened is probably something much more mundane than a mad Emperor tearing up vines to search for buried treasure. The fact of the matter is that there are many wines mentioned in Latin texts that have, for one reason or another, disappeared completely for no one reason, and it is likely that time simply took its toll on the famous Caecubum wine and the Abbuoto grape and they slowly faded away.
And they were thought to have been lost forever to history until a few decades ago. The story (in Italian) goes that, in some of the marshy areas around Lake Fondi about 50 miles south of Rome (where the original Caecuban countryside is purported to be), there were some old, neglected vines of a type that was thought to be the ancient Abbuoto. Cuttings were taken from these vines and nursed back to health. The healthy vines were definitely different from any other variety currently known, and the claim that they are the same as the ancient Abbuoto has remained unchallenged. It's certainly possible that it is the same ancient vine, but there's no real way to prove it. The vines.org encyclopedia indicates that there is between 700 and 800 hectares of land devoted to the Abbuoto grape throughout Italy (most of it centered in Lombardy and Piedmont, oddly enough), which seems like it doesn't match up with the recent "re-discovery" of the grape all that well, especially given that the grape seems to be grown in 12 different regions of Italy. I'm skeptical of the re-discovery story as it is presented, as it reeks of a marketing ploy to me, but I tend to be overly cynical about these kinds of things and invite you to draw your own conclusions.
Whatever the case may be, it is an undeniable fact that wines containing the Abbuoto grape are not exactly common. One of my local grocery stores has a full service liquor store on premise that I was wandering through one day when I came across the Villa Matilde "Cecubo" bottling for about $10. The amazing thing about it was that the only vintage available in the store was from 1999, so it must have sat on those shelves for nearly a decade before I came across it. Abbuoto is typically a blending grape, and this wine is no exception, containing 45% Abbuoto, 35% Primitivo and 20% Piedirosso. In the glass, this wine was a fairly deep ruby color and was going garnet at the edges. The nose was nicely aromatic with prune, fig, baking spice and leather. It was very earthy and appealing. On the palate, the wine was on the fuller side of medium with high acid and fine, dusty tannins. There were spicy black cherry, black plum and prune fruits with a savory leather and dusty earth character to it. There was also a pronounced cola flavor that was interesting, if a little odd. Overall, I enjoyed the wine quite a bit. It's difficult to find a 12 year old red wine for around $10, and luckily this wine had aged gracefully. I'd be very interested to try this in a more recent vintage, but as noted above, it's not easy to find. I believe there are some producers making wines with a higher percentage of Abbuoto in them, but good luck finding them.
That was a very long time ago, though, and seemingly no wine can resist the force of changing tastes and political turmoil. The Romans began to favor lighter wines and the dense, rich Cecubo began to fall out of favor. Our old friend Pliny blames the downfall of Caecubum on Nero. According to Pliny, the grape was grown in the marshy areas near the Gulf of Amyclae. He believes that its eradication was caused by the "carelessness of the cultivator," whatever that means, and by the building of a canal from Lake Avernus to Ostia by Emperor Nero. The only canal that I can find any evidence that Nero had anything to do with was the Corinth Canal, which was in Greece, so one wonders about the veracity of Pliny's account here. In fact, it seems as though the Roman General Agrippa actually built the canal a few decades before Nero came to power. Many Roman writers were overtly antagonistic to Nero in their texts, so it's totally possible that Pliny is just piling on him at this point. What actually happened is probably something much more mundane than a mad Emperor tearing up vines to search for buried treasure. The fact of the matter is that there are many wines mentioned in Latin texts that have, for one reason or another, disappeared completely for no one reason, and it is likely that time simply took its toll on the famous Caecubum wine and the Abbuoto grape and they slowly faded away.
And they were thought to have been lost forever to history until a few decades ago. The story (in Italian) goes that, in some of the marshy areas around Lake Fondi about 50 miles south of Rome (where the original Caecuban countryside is purported to be), there were some old, neglected vines of a type that was thought to be the ancient Abbuoto. Cuttings were taken from these vines and nursed back to health. The healthy vines were definitely different from any other variety currently known, and the claim that they are the same as the ancient Abbuoto has remained unchallenged. It's certainly possible that it is the same ancient vine, but there's no real way to prove it. The vines.org encyclopedia indicates that there is between 700 and 800 hectares of land devoted to the Abbuoto grape throughout Italy (most of it centered in Lombardy and Piedmont, oddly enough), which seems like it doesn't match up with the recent "re-discovery" of the grape all that well, especially given that the grape seems to be grown in 12 different regions of Italy. I'm skeptical of the re-discovery story as it is presented, as it reeks of a marketing ploy to me, but I tend to be overly cynical about these kinds of things and invite you to draw your own conclusions.
Whatever the case may be, it is an undeniable fact that wines containing the Abbuoto grape are not exactly common. One of my local grocery stores has a full service liquor store on premise that I was wandering through one day when I came across the Villa Matilde "Cecubo" bottling for about $10. The amazing thing about it was that the only vintage available in the store was from 1999, so it must have sat on those shelves for nearly a decade before I came across it. Abbuoto is typically a blending grape, and this wine is no exception, containing 45% Abbuoto, 35% Primitivo and 20% Piedirosso. In the glass, this wine was a fairly deep ruby color and was going garnet at the edges. The nose was nicely aromatic with prune, fig, baking spice and leather. It was very earthy and appealing. On the palate, the wine was on the fuller side of medium with high acid and fine, dusty tannins. There were spicy black cherry, black plum and prune fruits with a savory leather and dusty earth character to it. There was also a pronounced cola flavor that was interesting, if a little odd. Overall, I enjoyed the wine quite a bit. It's difficult to find a 12 year old red wine for around $10, and luckily this wine had aged gracefully. I'd be very interested to try this in a more recent vintage, but as noted above, it's not easy to find. I believe there are some producers making wines with a higher percentage of Abbuoto in them, but good luck finding them.
Monday, November 14, 2011
Verduzzo Friulano - Friuli, Italy
It seems like every time you turn around in Italy, there's an interesting grape with a complicated back story. Today's grape is no different, though the complications surrounding it are much easier to sort through than some of the others we've dealt with here.
The grape in question is Verduzzo, and having said that, we're immediately in trouble. It turns out that there are two grapes called Verduzzo which are not related to one another at all. There's Verduzzo Trevigiano, a high yielding vine that is thought to have originated in Sardinia. It's not generally well thought of, as the following quote from Nicolas Belfrage in his Barolo to Valpolicella indicates: "a variety of little character whose main virtue resides in the fact that it churns out regularly impressive volumes of plonk." The grape is also known as Verduzzo Dorato and is mostly grown in the Lison Pramaggiore and Piave DOCs in the Veneto.
And then there's Verduzzo Friulano, which is also grown in the Veneto but which seems to be native to Friuli. We're not completely out of the woods yet, though, as there are also a few sub-varieties of Verduzzo Friulano. Verduzzo Verde and Verduzzo Giallo are the two most common within Friuli. The Verde subvariety (so named because of the greenish color of the berries) is the lesser of the two, while the Giallo (so named for the yellowish color of the berries) is the more highly esteemed. The final member of the Verduzzo Friulano family is known as Verduzzo Rascie and it is differentiated from the others by its loose berry clusters which make it ideal for late harvest sweet wine production (the space between the berries allows air to circulate and reduces the chances that the grapes will develop rot or fungal diseases). Verduzzo Rascie is grown almost exclusively in the Ramandolo DOCG within Friuli.
On the whole, the sweet wines made from late harvested Verduzzo grapes are held in higher esteem than the dry table wines, but since a dry table wine is all I've been able to find, that's what we'll be taking a look at today. The winery who makes the bottle I was able to find is called I Clivi and they have 4 hectares of land in the Collio DOC and 8 hectares in the Colli Orientali del Friuli DOC areas of Friuli. They bottled their first wine in 1996, but the vines that they tend are much older than that, averaging between 40 and 60 years old. They bottle two "flagship" white wines called Brazan (from their Collio vineyards) and Galea (from their Colli Orientali del Friuli vineyards) which, until a few years ago, were blends of the local Tocai Friulano grape and Verduzzo (with some Malvasia). They decided to pull the Verduzzo and Malvasia out of these wines and make them both 100% Tocai Friulano. They also decided to bottle the Verduzzo as a varietal wine, naming it Bianco Degli Arzillari. The estate farms organically and the yields are very small, at a scant 2-3 tons per hectare. The white wines are fermented in temperature controlled stainless steel only using natural yeasts. If malolactic fermentation happens, it happens, and if not, it doesn't.
I found my bottle of the 2007 Bianco Degli Arzillari at Curtis Liquors for about $13. The 2007 was the most recent vintage available on the market, as the wines are aged sur lie for two years before bottling and are then aged in bottle for a few months after that. The wines are released when they are at least three years old. You may notice that this wine is bottled as an IGT and not as a DOC wine. It is legal to make a 100% Verduzzo wine in either Collio or Colli Orientali del Friuli, but since the grapes come from both of those regions, then it can't be labeled as either. In the glass, the wine was a medium lemon gold color. The nose was reserved with some pear, lemon peel, white flowers and a noticeable leesy kind of aroma (which, to me, is a kind cheesy or slightly funky smell). On the palate the wine was just slightly on the fuller side of medium with acidity just on the lower side of medium. There were flavors of white pear, ripe apple and apple skin with a clean, stony minerality on the finish. The flavor profile was pretty neutral overall, though it picked up a little bit of that leesy funk as it approached room temperature. It's well balanced and well made, but it's not the kind of white wine that gets me really excited, I guess. It's certainly a very nice wine for the price, but when I try to think about the kinds of occasions where I'd reach for this wine, I come up blank.
The grape in question is Verduzzo, and having said that, we're immediately in trouble. It turns out that there are two grapes called Verduzzo which are not related to one another at all. There's Verduzzo Trevigiano, a high yielding vine that is thought to have originated in Sardinia. It's not generally well thought of, as the following quote from Nicolas Belfrage in his Barolo to Valpolicella indicates: "a variety of little character whose main virtue resides in the fact that it churns out regularly impressive volumes of plonk." The grape is also known as Verduzzo Dorato and is mostly grown in the Lison Pramaggiore and Piave DOCs in the Veneto.
And then there's Verduzzo Friulano, which is also grown in the Veneto but which seems to be native to Friuli. We're not completely out of the woods yet, though, as there are also a few sub-varieties of Verduzzo Friulano. Verduzzo Verde and Verduzzo Giallo are the two most common within Friuli. The Verde subvariety (so named because of the greenish color of the berries) is the lesser of the two, while the Giallo (so named for the yellowish color of the berries) is the more highly esteemed. The final member of the Verduzzo Friulano family is known as Verduzzo Rascie and it is differentiated from the others by its loose berry clusters which make it ideal for late harvest sweet wine production (the space between the berries allows air to circulate and reduces the chances that the grapes will develop rot or fungal diseases). Verduzzo Rascie is grown almost exclusively in the Ramandolo DOCG within Friuli.
On the whole, the sweet wines made from late harvested Verduzzo grapes are held in higher esteem than the dry table wines, but since a dry table wine is all I've been able to find, that's what we'll be taking a look at today. The winery who makes the bottle I was able to find is called I Clivi and they have 4 hectares of land in the Collio DOC and 8 hectares in the Colli Orientali del Friuli DOC areas of Friuli. They bottled their first wine in 1996, but the vines that they tend are much older than that, averaging between 40 and 60 years old. They bottle two "flagship" white wines called Brazan (from their Collio vineyards) and Galea (from their Colli Orientali del Friuli vineyards) which, until a few years ago, were blends of the local Tocai Friulano grape and Verduzzo (with some Malvasia). They decided to pull the Verduzzo and Malvasia out of these wines and make them both 100% Tocai Friulano. They also decided to bottle the Verduzzo as a varietal wine, naming it Bianco Degli Arzillari. The estate farms organically and the yields are very small, at a scant 2-3 tons per hectare. The white wines are fermented in temperature controlled stainless steel only using natural yeasts. If malolactic fermentation happens, it happens, and if not, it doesn't.
I found my bottle of the 2007 Bianco Degli Arzillari at Curtis Liquors for about $13. The 2007 was the most recent vintage available on the market, as the wines are aged sur lie for two years before bottling and are then aged in bottle for a few months after that. The wines are released when they are at least three years old. You may notice that this wine is bottled as an IGT and not as a DOC wine. It is legal to make a 100% Verduzzo wine in either Collio or Colli Orientali del Friuli, but since the grapes come from both of those regions, then it can't be labeled as either. In the glass, the wine was a medium lemon gold color. The nose was reserved with some pear, lemon peel, white flowers and a noticeable leesy kind of aroma (which, to me, is a kind cheesy or slightly funky smell). On the palate the wine was just slightly on the fuller side of medium with acidity just on the lower side of medium. There were flavors of white pear, ripe apple and apple skin with a clean, stony minerality on the finish. The flavor profile was pretty neutral overall, though it picked up a little bit of that leesy funk as it approached room temperature. It's well balanced and well made, but it's not the kind of white wine that gets me really excited, I guess. It's certainly a very nice wine for the price, but when I try to think about the kinds of occasions where I'd reach for this wine, I come up blank.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Coda di Volpe - Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio, Campania, Italy
Buckle up friends and neighbors, because we're about to go on a wild ride through Roman literature, religious symbolism, volcanoes, fuzzy little animals and of course, a grape and some wine. What we're talking about today is the grape Coda di Volpe, which means "tail of the fox." The story goes that the grape is so named because the clusters have a slight curve to them that resembles a fox's tail, which you can kind of see in the picture to the left at the very bottom of the bunch. I started to look into who actually gave it that name, and ended up going on the journey you see below.
The source of the name Coda di Volpe is purported to be Pliny the Elder. Pliny wrote a massive 37 volume work entitled The Natural History which has an entire volume (volume 14) devoted to matters of the vine. Within Volume 14, there are 29 chapters dealing with various subjects related to grapes and vines, but it is chapter 4, entitled "Ninety-One Varieties of the Vine" where the mention of Coda di Volpe happens. I found an online translation of the work (translated by John Bostock and H.T. Riley in 1855) that translated the relevant block of Latin text as "the produce of the alopecis, which resembles in colour a fox's tail." Nearly every secondary source I've read about the grape maintains that the name comes from the shape of the bunch, so I was very curious to see that, in what appears to be the first mention of the grape in print, it is not the shape that is credited as being the source of the name, but rather the color.
The annotation maintains that this "Alopecis," or "fox-vine" is a currently unknown variety, but Nicolas Belfrage, in his Brunello to Zibibbo and Bastianich and Lynch in their Vino Italiano seem fairly convinced that this reference is in fact to Coda di Volpe. Their certainty seems to stem directly from the Latin text, where the phrase rendered in English as "fox's tail" is, in the original Latin, the phrase "caudas vulpium." It doesn't take a great deal of imagination to see how we got from "caudas vulpium" to Coda di Volpe. This is the only occurrence in the entire Natural History of the phrase "caudas vulpium" and it is the only appearance in any work of the word "Alopecis," so if we believe that Alopecis is the ancient name for Coda di Volpe and that the modern name comes from the Latin phrase "caudas vulpium," it's hard to say that the grapes are named for the shape of the bunch when the source material makes the link based on the color of the grapes. What is really interesting, though, is if you look at the passage in the original Latin on the same website, it allows you to click on individual words to get a translation. Clicking on "Alopecis" brings up the following definition: "a kind of vine which produces clusters resembling the tail of a fox."
The main problem here, I think, is due to the ambiguity of the original Latin text. The full sentence in Latin is: "contra damnantur etiam visu cinerea et rabuscula et asinusca, minus tamen caudas vulpium imitata alopecis." My Latin is a little rusty, but I don't see any reference in that phrase either to the color or the shape of the Alopecis. The end of the sentence reads to me something like "the Alopecis, which resembles a fox tail." The ambiguity and confusion seems to stem from trying to interpret the way in which the Alopecis resembles a fox-tail, because there is no explicit aspect of a fox-tail that the Alopecis is being said to resemble. The context of the sentence as a whole is centered around colors ("cinerea" is ash-colored, "rabuscula" is russet-colored and "asinusca" means something like donkey-colored), so reading the text in that light certainly makes the translation quoted above make more sense. We're making a comparison between all of these objects and color is what groups the first three together. It would be odd to suddenly shift to a different kind of feature (such as shape) for the final item in the comparison. Because of all that, I'm inclined to buy the color argument more than the shape one.
It is, of course, possible that the fox-tail shape story developed completely independently of anything else and there is absolutely no connection between Pliny's description of Alopecis and the modern day Coda di Volpe. That feels like it would have to be a pretty big coincidence, so I tend to doubt that's the case. What I suspect may have happened is that along the way, someone who wasn't familiar with Pliny's text was trying to understand for themselves how Coda di Volpe could have possibly gotten its name, and just decided that since it kind of looks like a fox-tail shape, that must be where it came from. The story has reinserted itself into the gloss on some of the texts and, in one case, has inserted itself wholesale directly into a translation. Philemon Holland's 1601 translation renders the passage: "and yet the fox-tailed grape Alopecis (for that it resembleth Rainards taile)." The bit in the parentheses there is not contained in the original Latin text at all and is a full insertion by the translator, indicating either that the shape explanation was relatively wide spread by this time, or indicating that Holland himself may be the source of the confusion.
If you've stuck through all that, then you're a real trooper and I appreciate it. Now that we've exhausted ourselves on the history of Coda di Volpe's name, we can take a look at the name of the region where this particular bottling is from, Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio. It turns out that this name is itself not without controversy. The most widely believed origin for the name Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio is that when Jesus was on his way up to Heaven, he looked down at the Bay of Naples and was so moved by its beauty that he wept tears of joy which fell on Mount Vesuvius, causing grapevines to spring up where they landed. Some believe that this is a modernization of an ancient Roman myth about Bacchus weeping and having vines spring up from his tears, but I'm having a hard time finding any source material for that. Another legend has it that when Lucifer was cast out of Heaven, he grabbed a piece of Paradise which fell with him, landing at the foot of Vesuvius, where it framed the Bay of Naples. Jesus wept when he saw the loss and his tears landed on the slopes of Vesuvius, where grapevines sprang up. Yet another story has it that when Lucifer was cast from Heaven, he landed at Vesuvius and began to destroy everything in sight. Jesus wept when he saw the destruction and, you guessed it, his tears landed on the slopes of Vesuvius and grapevines sprang up.
Whatever the true origin of the name is, we do know that some deity cried for some reason and those tears were so magical that grapes sprang up where they fell. The modern explanation for how a wine gets the name Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio on its label is much more mundane. There is a Vesuvio DOC that surrounds the ancient volcano and where the white wines must be made up of at least 80% Coda di Volpe and or Verdeca with a 35% minimum of Coda di Volpe and a maximum of 20% Falanghina and/or Greco. As you might imagine, the soils around Vesuvius are volcanic, which happens to be Coda di Volpe's favorite kind of soil to hang out on. The red and rosato wines must be at least 80% Piedirosso and/or Sciascinoso with at least 50% Piedirosso and at most 20% Aglianico. Any producer is entitled to put "Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio" on their label if the wines have a slightly higher alcohol content, a whopping one half-degree above normale. Essentially, the Lachryma Christi prefix to the wine's name is a different way to say Riserva and nothing more.
I was able to find a bottle of the 2009 Feudi di San Gregorio Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio from my friends at Bin Ends for about $14. The wine is about 80% Coda di Volpe and 20% Falanghina. The vines that the grapes come from are between 15 and 20 years old and are located directly around Vesuvius. The grapes are hand-sorted and gently pressed prior to undergoing primary fermentation in stainless steel with no malolactic fermentation. The wine is aged in steel on the lees for three months and then aged for one more month in bottle before release. In the glass, the wine was a pale lemon green color. The nose was nicely aromatic with ripe pear, lemon cream and apple. On the palate the wine was on the lighter side of medium with fairly high acid. There were flavors of creamy pear, apple peel, a touch of white peach and a little lemony citrus. The wine was delicate and subtle with a quiet, chalky kind of minerality on the finish. It wasn't a particularly complex wine, but it was fresh and clean tasting. It's a great summertime wine that would be an excellent match with light seafood or chicken dishes.
The source of the name Coda di Volpe is purported to be Pliny the Elder. Pliny wrote a massive 37 volume work entitled The Natural History which has an entire volume (volume 14) devoted to matters of the vine. Within Volume 14, there are 29 chapters dealing with various subjects related to grapes and vines, but it is chapter 4, entitled "Ninety-One Varieties of the Vine" where the mention of Coda di Volpe happens. I found an online translation of the work (translated by John Bostock and H.T. Riley in 1855) that translated the relevant block of Latin text as "the produce of the alopecis, which resembles in colour a fox's tail." Nearly every secondary source I've read about the grape maintains that the name comes from the shape of the bunch, so I was very curious to see that, in what appears to be the first mention of the grape in print, it is not the shape that is credited as being the source of the name, but rather the color.
The annotation maintains that this "Alopecis," or "fox-vine" is a currently unknown variety, but Nicolas Belfrage, in his Brunello to Zibibbo and Bastianich and Lynch in their Vino Italiano seem fairly convinced that this reference is in fact to Coda di Volpe. Their certainty seems to stem directly from the Latin text, where the phrase rendered in English as "fox's tail" is, in the original Latin, the phrase "caudas vulpium." It doesn't take a great deal of imagination to see how we got from "caudas vulpium" to Coda di Volpe. This is the only occurrence in the entire Natural History of the phrase "caudas vulpium" and it is the only appearance in any work of the word "Alopecis," so if we believe that Alopecis is the ancient name for Coda di Volpe and that the modern name comes from the Latin phrase "caudas vulpium," it's hard to say that the grapes are named for the shape of the bunch when the source material makes the link based on the color of the grapes. What is really interesting, though, is if you look at the passage in the original Latin on the same website, it allows you to click on individual words to get a translation. Clicking on "Alopecis" brings up the following definition: "a kind of vine which produces clusters resembling the tail of a fox."
The main problem here, I think, is due to the ambiguity of the original Latin text. The full sentence in Latin is: "contra damnantur etiam visu cinerea et rabuscula et asinusca, minus tamen caudas vulpium imitata alopecis." My Latin is a little rusty, but I don't see any reference in that phrase either to the color or the shape of the Alopecis. The end of the sentence reads to me something like "the Alopecis, which resembles a fox tail." The ambiguity and confusion seems to stem from trying to interpret the way in which the Alopecis resembles a fox-tail, because there is no explicit aspect of a fox-tail that the Alopecis is being said to resemble. The context of the sentence as a whole is centered around colors ("cinerea" is ash-colored, "rabuscula" is russet-colored and "asinusca" means something like donkey-colored), so reading the text in that light certainly makes the translation quoted above make more sense. We're making a comparison between all of these objects and color is what groups the first three together. It would be odd to suddenly shift to a different kind of feature (such as shape) for the final item in the comparison. Because of all that, I'm inclined to buy the color argument more than the shape one.
It is, of course, possible that the fox-tail shape story developed completely independently of anything else and there is absolutely no connection between Pliny's description of Alopecis and the modern day Coda di Volpe. That feels like it would have to be a pretty big coincidence, so I tend to doubt that's the case. What I suspect may have happened is that along the way, someone who wasn't familiar with Pliny's text was trying to understand for themselves how Coda di Volpe could have possibly gotten its name, and just decided that since it kind of looks like a fox-tail shape, that must be where it came from. The story has reinserted itself into the gloss on some of the texts and, in one case, has inserted itself wholesale directly into a translation. Philemon Holland's 1601 translation renders the passage: "and yet the fox-tailed grape Alopecis (for that it resembleth Rainards taile)." The bit in the parentheses there is not contained in the original Latin text at all and is a full insertion by the translator, indicating either that the shape explanation was relatively wide spread by this time, or indicating that Holland himself may be the source of the confusion.
If you've stuck through all that, then you're a real trooper and I appreciate it. Now that we've exhausted ourselves on the history of Coda di Volpe's name, we can take a look at the name of the region where this particular bottling is from, Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio. It turns out that this name is itself not without controversy. The most widely believed origin for the name Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio is that when Jesus was on his way up to Heaven, he looked down at the Bay of Naples and was so moved by its beauty that he wept tears of joy which fell on Mount Vesuvius, causing grapevines to spring up where they landed. Some believe that this is a modernization of an ancient Roman myth about Bacchus weeping and having vines spring up from his tears, but I'm having a hard time finding any source material for that. Another legend has it that when Lucifer was cast out of Heaven, he grabbed a piece of Paradise which fell with him, landing at the foot of Vesuvius, where it framed the Bay of Naples. Jesus wept when he saw the loss and his tears landed on the slopes of Vesuvius, where grapevines sprang up. Yet another story has it that when Lucifer was cast from Heaven, he landed at Vesuvius and began to destroy everything in sight. Jesus wept when he saw the destruction and, you guessed it, his tears landed on the slopes of Vesuvius and grapevines sprang up.
Whatever the true origin of the name is, we do know that some deity cried for some reason and those tears were so magical that grapes sprang up where they fell. The modern explanation for how a wine gets the name Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio on its label is much more mundane. There is a Vesuvio DOC that surrounds the ancient volcano and where the white wines must be made up of at least 80% Coda di Volpe and or Verdeca with a 35% minimum of Coda di Volpe and a maximum of 20% Falanghina and/or Greco. As you might imagine, the soils around Vesuvius are volcanic, which happens to be Coda di Volpe's favorite kind of soil to hang out on. The red and rosato wines must be at least 80% Piedirosso and/or Sciascinoso with at least 50% Piedirosso and at most 20% Aglianico. Any producer is entitled to put "Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio" on their label if the wines have a slightly higher alcohol content, a whopping one half-degree above normale. Essentially, the Lachryma Christi prefix to the wine's name is a different way to say Riserva and nothing more.
I was able to find a bottle of the 2009 Feudi di San Gregorio Lachryma Christi del Vesuvio from my friends at Bin Ends for about $14. The wine is about 80% Coda di Volpe and 20% Falanghina. The vines that the grapes come from are between 15 and 20 years old and are located directly around Vesuvius. The grapes are hand-sorted and gently pressed prior to undergoing primary fermentation in stainless steel with no malolactic fermentation. The wine is aged in steel on the lees for three months and then aged for one more month in bottle before release. In the glass, the wine was a pale lemon green color. The nose was nicely aromatic with ripe pear, lemon cream and apple. On the palate the wine was on the lighter side of medium with fairly high acid. There were flavors of creamy pear, apple peel, a touch of white peach and a little lemony citrus. The wine was delicate and subtle with a quiet, chalky kind of minerality on the finish. It wasn't a particularly complex wine, but it was fresh and clean tasting. It's a great summertime wine that would be an excellent match with light seafood or chicken dishes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




