It may be a stretch to consider Müller-Thurgau a fringe grape. It is planted on about 40,000 acres of land in Germany alone and as recently as the early 1990's, it was the most widely planted grape in that country (Riesling surpassed it in the late 1990's and has been pulling away ever since). There are also significant plantings of Müller-Thurgau in Austria, Switzerland, northern Italy, Slovenia and much of eastern Europe, and Müller-Thurgau is thought to be the most widely planted deliberate crossing on earth. I was on the fence about including Müller-Thurgau here, but there were a few things that swayed my decision. First of all, it was much more difficult than I thought to actually buy a bottle of varietal Müller-Thurgau wine. Secondly, when I finally did find a bottle, it was from Italy and not Germany, which isn't all that unusual, but it's not all that common either. The biggest reason I decided to write about Müller-Thurgau, though, was because of the really interesting story of its pedigree, and how that pedigree remained a mystery for more than 100 years. Much of the information below can be found in this paper, which ultimately solved the mystery of Müller-Thurgau's parentage in 2000, 118 years after its creation, and any papers that are not directly linked below are cited in that piece (most of them are in German and so even if I could access them, I'd have no idea what they said).
The Müller-Thurgau grape was created in 1882 by Dr. Herman Müller, who was born in the Swiss Canton (something akin to a state in the US) of Thurgau, which is located in the northeastern part of Switzerland. Thurgau is bordered to its northeast by Lake Constance, which separates Switzerland from southwestern Germany. Dr. Müller created this grape, known as No. 58, while he was working at the Geisenheim institute in Germany, but took it with him (along with the cuttings of about 150 other seedlings he had been working on) when he assumed the role of director at a research institution in Switzerland in 1891. No. 58 was first propagated in 1897, and in 1913, a Franconian grapevine inspector named August Dern brought cuttings of the vine back into Germany. Dern gave the grape the name Müller-Thurgau, and by 1930, experimental plots of the vine were being grown in every winegrowing region in Germany. Müller-Thurgau plantings soared after WWII when Germany was trying to rebuild their wine industry and replant their vineyards quickly, as Müller-Thurgau is a generous yielder that is very easy to work with in the vineyard and the winery. Plantings have been steadily declining in Germany since the late 1970's, but it is still responsible for about 15% of the total plantings in Germany, and is the 2nd most planted grape in that country.
The parentage for No. 58 was given as Riesling x Silvaner, but doubts about this were raised quickly. Dr. Müller wrote a letter to Dern at one point informing him that the cuttings that he brought into Germany from his lab were not the offspring of a Riesling x Silvaner cross, but no correct parentage was offered by Dr. Müller either. Some believed that the vine was a selfling of Riesling, meaning that a Riesling vine pollinated another Riesling vine and the resulting seed was planted. An ampelographical study done in 1957 by a man named Eichelsbacher attempted to rule out Silvaner as a parent by analyzing the shapes of the leaves and tips of Riesling, Silvaner, Müller-Thurgau, but ampelography has never been an exact science and Eichelsbacher's theory never gained universal acceptance.
In 1994, a German research team performed an RAPD analysis (an early form of genetic testing that has been supplanted by microsatellite testing in more recent years) on Riesling, Silvaner and Müller-Thurgau (source). Their analysis was able to show that Riesling was one of the parents of Müller-Thurgau, but Silvaner definitely was not the other. In 1996, another German research team proposed that the other parent could be a member of the Chassleas family and their research seemed to confirm their hunch. Their analysis only analyzed 8 microsatellite markers, though, and most scientists believe that at least 20 sites should be analyzed for conclusive results. In 1997, another research group ran a more extensive analysis and were able to rule out Chasselas as a parent of Müller-Thurgau, but they discovered that it was a grandparent. The other parent of Müller-Thurgau was actually a grape called Admirable de Courtiller, which is a table grape bred by a guy named Courtiller in the 19th Century by crossing Chasselas with Bicane.
The DNA evidence was unequivocal, but many found the results hard to believe. Müller-Thurgau did not resemble Admirable de Courtiller at all physically and you would expect that some physical characteristics would be passed on from a parent to its offspring. In 2000, another German research team set out to re-test Riesling, Admirable de Courtiller and Müller-Thurgau. The team requested leaf samples for each of the vines from two different holding facilities. The first set of samples came from Kolsterneuburg, Austria, which was where the 1997 research group got their material, while the second set came from Geilweilerhof, Germany. Once the leaves arrived from each institution, the team noticed that the samples for Admirable de Courtiller from each institution didn't match one another at all. Their ampelographic analysis led them to believe that the sample from Kolsterneuburg was actually from a grape called Madeleine Royale, which is a fairly common table grape bred in the mid 19th Century.
What had happened was essentially the same thing that happened with Hondarrabi Zuri in Spain. The accession for Madeleine Royale was mislabeled in Kolsterneuburg as Admirable de Courtiller, and so the team that obtained their samples from that holding facility in 1997 were misled as a result. When the 2000 research group ran the parentage studies on the correct version of Admirable de Courtiller, they were able to rule it out as a parent. The group also checked Madeleine Royale as a parent and confirmed that Müller-Thurgau was the result of crossing Riesling and Madeleine Royale.
The story isn't quite over, though. A guy named Moreau-Robert created Madeleine Royale in 1845, but there was no record of the grape's parentage. It was long suspected to be an offspring of Chasselas, but its pedigree wasn't scientifically investigated until 2010 when a Swiss duo was able to conclusively show that Chasselas could not be a parent to Madeleine Royale. What was more surprising, though, is that they were able to show that Pinot and Schiava Grossa were almost certainly the real parents of Madeleine Royale, meaning that Pinot and Schiava are also the grandparents of Müller-Thurgau.
There is still some confusion in many reference materials about Müller-Thurgau's true parentage. Oz Clarke's Grapes & Wines and Stephen Brook's The Wines of Germany continue to list the parents as Riesling x Admirable de Courtiller, and when I first learned about Müller-Thurgau a few years ago, the material that I was reading (which I can't recollect or seem to find again) listed the parentage as Riesling x Silvaner. This mistaken parentage is perhaps still perpetrated in part by the fact that one of Müller-Thurgau's most widely accepted synonyms is Rivaner which is clearly just a contraction of Riesling and Silvaner. There are a lot of German crossings that were the result of a Riesling x Silvaner cross, because many scientists have been trying to combine the quality of Riesling and the hardiness and high yields of Silvaner, but so far none have been particularly successful.
I was able to try a 2008 Andrian0 Müller-Thurgau from the Alto Adige region of Italy. I picked this bottle up for about $13 locally. In the glass the wine was a medium lemon gold color with a greenish tint. The nose was fairly intense with white pear, lemon, white flowers and peach. On the palate the wine was medium bodied with medium acidity. There were flavors of tart green apple, lemon, pear and under-ripe pineapple. It finished with a bitter, pithy kind of flavor that wasn't all that nice. Overall this wine was fairly non-descript and average, as a lot of wines made from this grape tend to be. The Oxford Companion to Wine calls it "the bane of German wine production" because of the oceans of bland, sickly sweet wines that were pumped out of Germany from the 1970's up to the modern day. This is better than most of the junk that comes out of Germany under the Müller-Thurgau or Rivaner name, but it's still nothing all that exciting. The story of the grape is definitely more fascinating than the wines that are made from it.
A blog devoted to exploring wines made from unusual grape varieties and/or grown in unfamiliar regions all over the world. All wines are purchased by me from shops in the Boston metro area or directly from wineries that I have visited. If a reviewed bottle is a free sample, that fact is acknowledged prior to the bottle's review. I do not receive any compensation from any of the wineries, wine shops or companies that I mention on the blog.
Showing posts with label Alto Adige. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alto Adige. Show all posts
Thursday, August 9, 2012
Thursday, January 19, 2012
Blatterle - Alto Adige, Italy
I live for wines like the one I'll be writing about today. It's a wine made from a very unusual grape that is grown in a very small region of Italy and, essentially, vinified by pretty much only a single producer. We've taken a look at a few wines like this in the past. The Roscetto from Lazio and the Casetta from the Veneto are both similar in terms of their obscurity. While I love to find wines like these, it can be a real pain to try to write about them. When you pass a certain point of obscurity, doing the research for a blog post becomes a real struggle. For most of my posts, the real challenge is in sifting through all the information I have to try and find the most interesting parts that I can write about. With some grapes, though, the challenge becomes trying to find any information at all about them. The grapes mentioned above, as well as today's grape, Blatterle, are not mentioned in any books that I have (aside from a passing mention of Casetta in Bastianich and Lynch's Vino Italiano) and are not heavily referenced online either. My life gets a lot more difficult once I go diving past a certain level of obscurity and find myself in the murky waters of the virtually unknown.
I mention in the Casetta and Roscetto posts linked above that all of the information available about those particular grapes comes from the people who are selling you the bottle, which always makes me a little uneasy. With Blatterle, the person who is growing the grapes and making the wine doesn't really have much of an online presence, so we are denied even that much access. In this case, the source of most of the information is the importer of the wine, Louis/Dressner, whose founder Joe Dressner sadly passed away just a few months back. I feel a little better about using the importer (this one in particular) rather than the winery itself as the primary source partly because the importer has a good reputation within the wine community, but mostly because the content of their site, or at least the part dealing this grape, is very factually oriented, and if it's a sales pitch, it's one of the driest ones I've ever come across. That sounds like a dig, but it's actually a really good thing in my opinion. I'm a "just the facts" kind of person and am much more interested in winery sites that sound more like an encyclopedia than like a commercial.
Here is essentially what we know about Blatterle. It is an old variety that is thought to be native to the Isarco River Valley in the Alto Adige. The name Blatterle means "little leaf" in German (remember that the Alto Adige region is a weird kind of mixture of German and Italian cultures), which, I guess, means that this vine may have smaller than average leaves. They say that the grapes themselves are kind of oval-shaped and golden colored, but I don't see it in the pictures that I was able to find. It seems that historically the grape was used either for grape juice production or in the production of a lightish, everyday kind of wine.
The grape is grown pretty much exclusively by the Mayr-Nusserhof estate, which is located near (or possibly in) the city of Bolzano on the Isarco River. The family who owns the estate are named Mayr while there are conflicting reports about where the Nusserhof comes from. The importer says that it's a reference to some hazelnut trees (Nuss is the German word for nut) that used to surround the house but which were cut down as the city of Bolzano has impinged further and further on the Mayr family's spread, which is currently about 2.5 hectares of organically farmed land. A shop in North Carolina presents the alternate theory that one of the current owner's relatives, a man named Josef Meyr Nusser, had the street named after him because of his actions in World War II, where his opposition to the Nazi regime led him to become a conscientious objector when the Nazis were recruiting soldiers from his occupied town. As you might imagine, the Nazis weren't especially kind to opposition of any sort and Josef died in a concentration camp as a Catholic martyr. The second story is not only much better, but is actually more plausible, so that's the one I'm going to choose to believe.
I was able to pick up a bottle of the 2007 Nusserhof "Blaterle" from my friends at Curtis Liquors for about $23. You may notice that the name of the wine is "Blaterle" rather than Blatterle. Since the Blatterle grape is not approved for use in any DOC wine, the winery bottles this as a Vino da Tavola, which has the restriction that you cannot print a place name, grape name or vintage on the label of the wine. Just by dropping one of the T's in the middle of the word, the winery is able to dodge these restrictions (the vintage is hidden at the bottom of the label where it says L07, the last two numbers being the last two digits of the vintage year). In the glass the wine was a pale greenish lemon color. The nose was fairly reserved with some pear fruit and something slightly nutty. As the wine approached room temperature, there was something vaguely floral that started to show up, but never in any serious amount. On the palate the wine was medium bodied with medium to low acidity. The wine had a very minerally flavor profile with some lean pear fruit and lemon peel, but not a whole lot. This wine was probably on the wrong end of its life span and was suffering slightly for it. It's interesting to compare my tasting notes with Jakob's Bowl who did his tasting a little over a year after I did and with a bottle that was one vintage year newer. My bottle lacked the explosive floral notes that his had and mine had definitely picked up more pithy citrus in the bottle. I'm interested in trying a younger version and will keep my eyes peeled and fingers crossed.
I mention in the Casetta and Roscetto posts linked above that all of the information available about those particular grapes comes from the people who are selling you the bottle, which always makes me a little uneasy. With Blatterle, the person who is growing the grapes and making the wine doesn't really have much of an online presence, so we are denied even that much access. In this case, the source of most of the information is the importer of the wine, Louis/Dressner, whose founder Joe Dressner sadly passed away just a few months back. I feel a little better about using the importer (this one in particular) rather than the winery itself as the primary source partly because the importer has a good reputation within the wine community, but mostly because the content of their site, or at least the part dealing this grape, is very factually oriented, and if it's a sales pitch, it's one of the driest ones I've ever come across. That sounds like a dig, but it's actually a really good thing in my opinion. I'm a "just the facts" kind of person and am much more interested in winery sites that sound more like an encyclopedia than like a commercial.
Here is essentially what we know about Blatterle. It is an old variety that is thought to be native to the Isarco River Valley in the Alto Adige. The name Blatterle means "little leaf" in German (remember that the Alto Adige region is a weird kind of mixture of German and Italian cultures), which, I guess, means that this vine may have smaller than average leaves. They say that the grapes themselves are kind of oval-shaped and golden colored, but I don't see it in the pictures that I was able to find. It seems that historically the grape was used either for grape juice production or in the production of a lightish, everyday kind of wine.
The grape is grown pretty much exclusively by the Mayr-Nusserhof estate, which is located near (or possibly in) the city of Bolzano on the Isarco River. The family who owns the estate are named Mayr while there are conflicting reports about where the Nusserhof comes from. The importer says that it's a reference to some hazelnut trees (Nuss is the German word for nut) that used to surround the house but which were cut down as the city of Bolzano has impinged further and further on the Mayr family's spread, which is currently about 2.5 hectares of organically farmed land. A shop in North Carolina presents the alternate theory that one of the current owner's relatives, a man named Josef Meyr Nusser, had the street named after him because of his actions in World War II, where his opposition to the Nazi regime led him to become a conscientious objector when the Nazis were recruiting soldiers from his occupied town. As you might imagine, the Nazis weren't especially kind to opposition of any sort and Josef died in a concentration camp as a Catholic martyr. The second story is not only much better, but is actually more plausible, so that's the one I'm going to choose to believe.
I was able to pick up a bottle of the 2007 Nusserhof "Blaterle" from my friends at Curtis Liquors for about $23. You may notice that the name of the wine is "Blaterle" rather than Blatterle. Since the Blatterle grape is not approved for use in any DOC wine, the winery bottles this as a Vino da Tavola, which has the restriction that you cannot print a place name, grape name or vintage on the label of the wine. Just by dropping one of the T's in the middle of the word, the winery is able to dodge these restrictions (the vintage is hidden at the bottom of the label where it says L07, the last two numbers being the last two digits of the vintage year). In the glass the wine was a pale greenish lemon color. The nose was fairly reserved with some pear fruit and something slightly nutty. As the wine approached room temperature, there was something vaguely floral that started to show up, but never in any serious amount. On the palate the wine was medium bodied with medium to low acidity. The wine had a very minerally flavor profile with some lean pear fruit and lemon peel, but not a whole lot. This wine was probably on the wrong end of its life span and was suffering slightly for it. It's interesting to compare my tasting notes with Jakob's Bowl who did his tasting a little over a year after I did and with a bottle that was one vintage year newer. My bottle lacked the explosive floral notes that his had and mine had definitely picked up more pithy citrus in the bottle. I'm interested in trying a younger version and will keep my eyes peeled and fingers crossed.
Friday, June 3, 2011
Lagrein - Alto Adige, Italy
Lagrein is one of those grapes that slowly seems to be coming into fashion. Eric Asimov has recently written about it in his New York Times column, it was profiled on WineLibrary.tv a few years back, and it has started to show up in some email specials and even on some restaurant menus (one of the wines I'll be writing about below is from a local restaurant). While the interest the grape is generating may be a relatively recent phenomenon, the grape itself is anything but new.
Let's get some history out of the way first: some sources say that Lagrein was first mentioned in print in the 17th Century, but other sources claim that mentions of the grape can be dated as far back as 1379 AD. For awhile, it was thought that the grape came over from Greece and that the source of the name "Lagrein" was either from the Greek word lagarinthos, which means "hanging," or from the Greek Colony of Lagaria in southern Italy. Today, most people seem to think that the name comes from the Lagarina Valley in Trentino, just south of Alto Adige. Whatever the source of the grape's name, its origin is no longer in doubt: genetic testing has shown that one of its parent grapes is Teroldego and it is a full sibling of Marzemino, both native Trentino varietals (Vouillamoz, J., & Grando, M. (2006) Genealogy of wine grape cultivars: ‘Pinot’ is related to ‘Syrah’. Heredity, 97(2), 102-110.). (**UPDATE** Lagrein's parentage has been confirmed as Teroldego x Schiava Gentile according to: Cipriani, G. et al. The SSR-based molecular profile of 1005 grapevine (Vitis vinifera L.) accessions uncovers new synonymy and parentages, and reveals a large admixture amongst varieties of different geographic origin. 2010. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 121: 1569-1585.). These relations strongly indicate that the grape was born in the Trentino/Alto-Adige region. Today, it is extraordinarily difficult, but not impossible, to find Lagrein anywhere outside of Alto Adige. Australia seems to be the only other place on earth bothering with the grape, though production there is limited to a handful of producers (California has some vines, but nowhere near enough to be considered a player in the Lagrein game).
The vine was once more widespread through Alto Adige than it is today, but it was supplanted by Schiava to a large extent. Both Schiava and Lagrein are capable of very high yields, and while I've read that Schiava was supplanting Lagrein because of its greater resistance to disease, my feeling is that fashion probably played a larger role. The focus on denser, darker red wines is largely a product of recent history as, traditionally, most red wines were fairly light in body and color (many historians think that the great "clarets" from Bordeaux in the 17th and 18th centuries were closer to modern day rosé wines than red wines). In general, Lagrein is not a light wine and it has the double-whammy of high acidity and very high tannins. My feeling is that Schiava was more widely planted because the wines produced from the grape were more approachable and user-friendly than the wines being made from Lagrein. A good deal of the Lagrein production was used to beef up the Schiava a bit, as Schiava can be bewilderingly light in color for a red wine. It's also somewhat telling that, for quite awhile, Lagrein was more lauded for its ability to produce an excellent rosé than for its ability to produce red wine (it still has a great reputation for rosé production, though it is much more difficult to find rosé wines made from it than regular red wines).
Current fashion has swung in the opposite direction and today's consumer is more interested in denser, heavier red wines with more body and fruit. While Lagrein does have high acid and high tannin, it also has the great equalizer of intense fruit concentration that can round out the sharpness and provide a lot of flesh on the otherwise pretty angular skeleton that the Lagrein grape carries around. The key, though, is a focus on quality in the vineyard. As mentioned above, Lagrein has the capacity to yield explosively but when allowed to do so, the fruit gets diluted and the structure sticks out in all the wrong places. Canopy management and restricted yields are especially key for producers who are looking to produce quality wines from Lagrein. Many producers are heeding the call, though, and Lagrein is starting to take back some of the vineyard area from Schiava and to generate more of a buzz in the international community.
The first wine I was able to try is one I found on a local restaurant wine list. Sel de la Terre was offering the 2003 vintage of the Abtei Muri-Gries Riserva for $40 a bottle when I was there in April 2011 (the picture on the side shows the 2000 vintage because I wasn't able to snap a picture in the restaurant and this was the best looking label I could find). I jotted my notes down on some scrap paper so this isn't a complete tasting note, but the bottle was so good I definitely wanted to be able to write about it here. The lighting in the restaurant was pretty dim, but the color on this wine was an obvious, dense, inky purple color. The nose was pretty shy on this and never developed very much. On the palate, though, the wine was full, dense and richly extracted with acidity on the higher side of medium and grainy tannins. The palate was full of rich, ripe purple fruits and nice earthy, leathery notes. It was broad and very well balanced with a medium finish. This wine is produced in a monastery in Alto-Adige from three different estate vineyards that only total 9 hectares. Some of the vines on these estates are 80+ years old. The wine is stainless-steel vinified and then aged in wooden barrels (probably some new oak, but I doubt it's 100%) for 16 months prior to release.
The second wine I tried was the 2009 Georg Mumelter Griesbauerhof which I picked up for $22. Again, the wine had a deep, inky purple color with a generous nose of crushed blackberry, blueberry, black cherry with some jammy notes to it as well. The palate was full bodied with nice acidity and plush, ripe tannins. There was smoky black cherry and blackberry fruit with some earthy leather rounding it out. This was a bit more polished than the Muri-Gries, but really lacked the complexity and depth of flavor of that wine. The finish comes up pretty short on this bottle, but overall, it's a very good effort. Barbeque is the first thing that comes to mind for me with these wines, as they have the structure and the fruit to stand up to smoked meats and heavy sauces. I almost hate to say it, but a good comparison here is with well-made Australian Shiraz as they both have that dense core of primary fruit with nice acid and enough tannin to prevent them from tasting like fruit soup. If you run across Lagrein in your local shop, give it a shot and serve it with your next cook out.
**UPDATE**
I was recently able to track down a bottle of the 2009 Muri-Gries Rosato made from 100% Lagrein grapes in the Alto Adige region of Italy. I picked this bottle up from my friends at Curtis Liquors for about $8. In the glass this wine was a bright cherry red color reminiscent of maraschino cherry juice. The nose was somewhat reserved with red cherry and fresh cut strawberry fruits. On the palate the wine was on the fuller side of medium with fairly high acid. There were flavors of Rainier cherry and sour cherry along with some fresh cut strawberry and touch of watermelon. The flavors were a little bit washed out and muted here, as this wine is probably not meant to sit around for a few years before having its cork pulled. This wine does typically retail for about double what I paid and I knew when I bought it that it was an end-of-the-vintage sale and that it might not be showing its best. I did still find it enjoyable and thought that it was miles better than most rosé wines at this price point.
Let's get some history out of the way first: some sources say that Lagrein was first mentioned in print in the 17th Century, but other sources claim that mentions of the grape can be dated as far back as 1379 AD. For awhile, it was thought that the grape came over from Greece and that the source of the name "Lagrein" was either from the Greek word lagarinthos, which means "hanging," or from the Greek Colony of Lagaria in southern Italy. Today, most people seem to think that the name comes from the Lagarina Valley in Trentino, just south of Alto Adige. Whatever the source of the grape's name, its origin is no longer in doubt: genetic testing has shown that one of its parent grapes is Teroldego and it is a full sibling of Marzemino, both native Trentino varietals (Vouillamoz, J., & Grando, M. (2006) Genealogy of wine grape cultivars: ‘Pinot’ is related to ‘Syrah’. Heredity, 97(2), 102-110.). (**UPDATE** Lagrein's parentage has been confirmed as Teroldego x Schiava Gentile according to: Cipriani, G. et al. The SSR-based molecular profile of 1005 grapevine (Vitis vinifera L.) accessions uncovers new synonymy and parentages, and reveals a large admixture amongst varieties of different geographic origin. 2010. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 121: 1569-1585.). These relations strongly indicate that the grape was born in the Trentino/Alto-Adige region. Today, it is extraordinarily difficult, but not impossible, to find Lagrein anywhere outside of Alto Adige. Australia seems to be the only other place on earth bothering with the grape, though production there is limited to a handful of producers (California has some vines, but nowhere near enough to be considered a player in the Lagrein game).
The vine was once more widespread through Alto Adige than it is today, but it was supplanted by Schiava to a large extent. Both Schiava and Lagrein are capable of very high yields, and while I've read that Schiava was supplanting Lagrein because of its greater resistance to disease, my feeling is that fashion probably played a larger role. The focus on denser, darker red wines is largely a product of recent history as, traditionally, most red wines were fairly light in body and color (many historians think that the great "clarets" from Bordeaux in the 17th and 18th centuries were closer to modern day rosé wines than red wines). In general, Lagrein is not a light wine and it has the double-whammy of high acidity and very high tannins. My feeling is that Schiava was more widely planted because the wines produced from the grape were more approachable and user-friendly than the wines being made from Lagrein. A good deal of the Lagrein production was used to beef up the Schiava a bit, as Schiava can be bewilderingly light in color for a red wine. It's also somewhat telling that, for quite awhile, Lagrein was more lauded for its ability to produce an excellent rosé than for its ability to produce red wine (it still has a great reputation for rosé production, though it is much more difficult to find rosé wines made from it than regular red wines).
Current fashion has swung in the opposite direction and today's consumer is more interested in denser, heavier red wines with more body and fruit. While Lagrein does have high acid and high tannin, it also has the great equalizer of intense fruit concentration that can round out the sharpness and provide a lot of flesh on the otherwise pretty angular skeleton that the Lagrein grape carries around. The key, though, is a focus on quality in the vineyard. As mentioned above, Lagrein has the capacity to yield explosively but when allowed to do so, the fruit gets diluted and the structure sticks out in all the wrong places. Canopy management and restricted yields are especially key for producers who are looking to produce quality wines from Lagrein. Many producers are heeding the call, though, and Lagrein is starting to take back some of the vineyard area from Schiava and to generate more of a buzz in the international community.
The first wine I was able to try is one I found on a local restaurant wine list. Sel de la Terre was offering the 2003 vintage of the Abtei Muri-Gries Riserva for $40 a bottle when I was there in April 2011 (the picture on the side shows the 2000 vintage because I wasn't able to snap a picture in the restaurant and this was the best looking label I could find). I jotted my notes down on some scrap paper so this isn't a complete tasting note, but the bottle was so good I definitely wanted to be able to write about it here. The lighting in the restaurant was pretty dim, but the color on this wine was an obvious, dense, inky purple color. The nose was pretty shy on this and never developed very much. On the palate, though, the wine was full, dense and richly extracted with acidity on the higher side of medium and grainy tannins. The palate was full of rich, ripe purple fruits and nice earthy, leathery notes. It was broad and very well balanced with a medium finish. This wine is produced in a monastery in Alto-Adige from three different estate vineyards that only total 9 hectares. Some of the vines on these estates are 80+ years old. The wine is stainless-steel vinified and then aged in wooden barrels (probably some new oak, but I doubt it's 100%) for 16 months prior to release.
The second wine I tried was the 2009 Georg Mumelter Griesbauerhof which I picked up for $22. Again, the wine had a deep, inky purple color with a generous nose of crushed blackberry, blueberry, black cherry with some jammy notes to it as well. The palate was full bodied with nice acidity and plush, ripe tannins. There was smoky black cherry and blackberry fruit with some earthy leather rounding it out. This was a bit more polished than the Muri-Gries, but really lacked the complexity and depth of flavor of that wine. The finish comes up pretty short on this bottle, but overall, it's a very good effort. Barbeque is the first thing that comes to mind for me with these wines, as they have the structure and the fruit to stand up to smoked meats and heavy sauces. I almost hate to say it, but a good comparison here is with well-made Australian Shiraz as they both have that dense core of primary fruit with nice acid and enough tannin to prevent them from tasting like fruit soup. If you run across Lagrein in your local shop, give it a shot and serve it with your next cook out.
**UPDATE**
Monday, May 23, 2011
Kerner - Valle Isarco, Alto Adige, Italy
By all accounts, today's post should take us back into Germany. After all, the Kerner grape was created in 1929 by August Herold in Lauffen, Germany, by crossing Riesling and Schiava (also known as Trollinger or Vernatsch). In the mid-90's, Kerner was the third most planted white grape in Germany and occupied about 8,000 hectares of land, accounting for about 7.5% of total German vineyard land. Plantings have fallen in recent years, though, and Kerner today accounts for about 4% of total German vineyard area, placing it eighth among German white grapes. For comparison's sake, Scheurebe accounts for less than 2% of vineyard area, and German Scheurebe, while not exactly everywhere, is easier to find than German Kerner for some reason. In fact, both of the wines I'll be writing about today are from Alto Adige in Italy and every Kerner that I've seen on the shelf has been from this same region.
Why might that be? Well, I think it has something to do with the image of each country in the mind of the American consumer (it may be more widespread than that, but I'm not going to presume on behalf of other nationalities...I hesitate even here to generalize about the "American consumer"). As mentioned in the Scheurebe post, when you have a look at the German section of your local wine shop, I'm guessing that an overwhelming majority of the bottles on the shelf are Riesling even though Riesling itself only accounts for 22% of the vineyard area in Germany (most shops I frequent run between 90 - 100% Riesling in their German sections). I suspect that American consumers have associated Germany with Riesling to such an extent that there just isn't a lot of interest over here for wines made from other grapes, even though Germany certainly has a wealth of them. Italy, on the other hand, has kind of a reputation for wines made from all kinds of different grapes, so consumers are probably more willing to take a chance on a grape they've never heard of from Italy. In fact, the Italian landscape of grapes almost forces consumers to be open to variety unless they want to drink only Chianti for the rest of their life. I get a sense that for most people, Germany is practically equivalent to Riesling (or, worse, Liebfraumilch), so wine made from others grapes are a tougher sell. I've actually had more luck finding Müller-Thurgau wines from Italy than I have from Germany, and Müller-Thurgau is Germany's second most planted white grape, accounting for nearly 14% of the total vineyard surface!
So even if we grant that my little theory has some merit, some may still be scratching their heads and wondering what German grapes like Kerner and Müller-Thurgau are doing in Italy in the first place. Well, as mentioned in the post about Schiava, the Alto Adige region is on the northern border of Italy and, historically, has been under the control of the Austro-Hungarian empire (the territory was ceded to Italy only as recently as the end of World War I). The culture here is very Germanic and many of the grape varieties grown here reflect that. Kerner seems to have a special affinity for a sub-region in the north-central part of Alto Adige called Valle Isarco which sits directly on the border with Austria. This is Alpine country, though the areas right around the Isarco river are a little lower as the river has carved out the valley over time. Many of the vineyards here are at altitude, though, ranging from 500 - 1000 meters above sea level. As you might expect, this is definitely white wine country and Kerner seems to grow particularly well on these elevated slopes.
Most crossings are created to deal with specific climatic conditions and Kerner is no exception. It buds late so it misses most of the spring frosts, which is a big deal in the climates it inhabits. It does not have any specific soil requirements and is not particularly susceptible to any of the major moisture-related diseases that prey on vines (molds, rots, etc.). Like pretty much all successful crossings, Kerner can yield very large crops which, if left unchecked, can create thin, dilute wines. If properly managed in the vineyard and if given enough time to ripen fully (it is often not fully ripe until well into October), it can create exotically perfumed wines that resemble Riesling.
The first wine I was able to try was from the Cantina Valle Isarco, a cooperative within the Valle Isarco with over 130 members. The word "Eisacktaler" on the label is the Germanic term for the Valle Isarco region. The vintage on my bottle was 2006 and I paid about $18 for it. In the glass, the wine was a lemon yellow color with aromas of petrol, melon and honeysuckle. "Oily flowers" was the sum-up phrase I used for the nose. On the palate, the wine was dry with a rich, oily texture and medium acidity. There were lean fruit flavors of white peaches with honey and a touch of leafy mint on the finish. There was a nice, flinty kind of minerality running through the wine as well. The petrol aromas and flavors were pretty strong here and I'd guess this wine probably didn't have a lot of time left before it fell apart completely. If the acid level were a little higher here, this would be a fantastic wine, but the rich, oily texture didn't have much to support it. The alcohol here is also sky high for a white wine, clocking in at a monstrous 14.5%. This wine was certainly made from very ripe grapes and was pretty good, considering its age. This had the body to stand up to a lot, but I'd avoid foods with acidity as they'd probably make this taste a little flabbier than it really is. Thick sauces or chicken or pork are probably the ticket here.
The second wine I was able to try was from the Abbazia di Novacella winery. The vintage was 2009 and the price was $22. In the glass, this was a medium lemon green color with intense aromatics of grapefruit, lemon, melon and a touch of grassy herbs. The body was on the fuller side of medium with the same thick, oily texture as the prior bottle. The acid level was medium and there were flavors of ripe melon and grapefruit pith with a touch of lemony citrus. Considering how aromatic the wine was, it was a bit of a letdown on the palate as that exuberance didn't really carry over. The alcohol was very high here again (14%) and was much more obvious and in the way than on the previous bottle. All in all, this reminded me more of a Sancerre style Sauvignon Blanc than a Riesling which makes me wonder whether these grapes were a little underripe or whether they may something else blended in here (the DOC regulations stipulate that if a varietal is stated, the wine only needs to be comprised of 85 - 100% of that varietal with the rest made up of "other local similar varietals"). My money's on slightly underripe grapes, for what it's worth, and I would consider pairing this the same way I would the wine above, really, as it still had the big body with the lackluster acidity.
All in all, Kerner probably isn't going to replace Riesling any time soon, but it is a refreshing change of pace. I'd recommend drinking these wines young and pairing them with fairly hefty dishes that aren't particularly acidic. Also, because of the body and the high alcohol content, these feel more like autumn or winter weather whites to me, as they're not all that refreshing to drink on their own. Alto Adige has plenty of light zippy wines that will serve you better for the warm months ahead.
Why might that be? Well, I think it has something to do with the image of each country in the mind of the American consumer (it may be more widespread than that, but I'm not going to presume on behalf of other nationalities...I hesitate even here to generalize about the "American consumer"). As mentioned in the Scheurebe post, when you have a look at the German section of your local wine shop, I'm guessing that an overwhelming majority of the bottles on the shelf are Riesling even though Riesling itself only accounts for 22% of the vineyard area in Germany (most shops I frequent run between 90 - 100% Riesling in their German sections). I suspect that American consumers have associated Germany with Riesling to such an extent that there just isn't a lot of interest over here for wines made from other grapes, even though Germany certainly has a wealth of them. Italy, on the other hand, has kind of a reputation for wines made from all kinds of different grapes, so consumers are probably more willing to take a chance on a grape they've never heard of from Italy. In fact, the Italian landscape of grapes almost forces consumers to be open to variety unless they want to drink only Chianti for the rest of their life. I get a sense that for most people, Germany is practically equivalent to Riesling (or, worse, Liebfraumilch), so wine made from others grapes are a tougher sell. I've actually had more luck finding Müller-Thurgau wines from Italy than I have from Germany, and Müller-Thurgau is Germany's second most planted white grape, accounting for nearly 14% of the total vineyard surface!
So even if we grant that my little theory has some merit, some may still be scratching their heads and wondering what German grapes like Kerner and Müller-Thurgau are doing in Italy in the first place. Well, as mentioned in the post about Schiava, the Alto Adige region is on the northern border of Italy and, historically, has been under the control of the Austro-Hungarian empire (the territory was ceded to Italy only as recently as the end of World War I). The culture here is very Germanic and many of the grape varieties grown here reflect that. Kerner seems to have a special affinity for a sub-region in the north-central part of Alto Adige called Valle Isarco which sits directly on the border with Austria. This is Alpine country, though the areas right around the Isarco river are a little lower as the river has carved out the valley over time. Many of the vineyards here are at altitude, though, ranging from 500 - 1000 meters above sea level. As you might expect, this is definitely white wine country and Kerner seems to grow particularly well on these elevated slopes.
Most crossings are created to deal with specific climatic conditions and Kerner is no exception. It buds late so it misses most of the spring frosts, which is a big deal in the climates it inhabits. It does not have any specific soil requirements and is not particularly susceptible to any of the major moisture-related diseases that prey on vines (molds, rots, etc.). Like pretty much all successful crossings, Kerner can yield very large crops which, if left unchecked, can create thin, dilute wines. If properly managed in the vineyard and if given enough time to ripen fully (it is often not fully ripe until well into October), it can create exotically perfumed wines that resemble Riesling.
The first wine I was able to try was from the Cantina Valle Isarco, a cooperative within the Valle Isarco with over 130 members. The word "Eisacktaler" on the label is the Germanic term for the Valle Isarco region. The vintage on my bottle was 2006 and I paid about $18 for it. In the glass, the wine was a lemon yellow color with aromas of petrol, melon and honeysuckle. "Oily flowers" was the sum-up phrase I used for the nose. On the palate, the wine was dry with a rich, oily texture and medium acidity. There were lean fruit flavors of white peaches with honey and a touch of leafy mint on the finish. There was a nice, flinty kind of minerality running through the wine as well. The petrol aromas and flavors were pretty strong here and I'd guess this wine probably didn't have a lot of time left before it fell apart completely. If the acid level were a little higher here, this would be a fantastic wine, but the rich, oily texture didn't have much to support it. The alcohol here is also sky high for a white wine, clocking in at a monstrous 14.5%. This wine was certainly made from very ripe grapes and was pretty good, considering its age. This had the body to stand up to a lot, but I'd avoid foods with acidity as they'd probably make this taste a little flabbier than it really is. Thick sauces or chicken or pork are probably the ticket here.
The second wine I was able to try was from the Abbazia di Novacella winery. The vintage was 2009 and the price was $22. In the glass, this was a medium lemon green color with intense aromatics of grapefruit, lemon, melon and a touch of grassy herbs. The body was on the fuller side of medium with the same thick, oily texture as the prior bottle. The acid level was medium and there were flavors of ripe melon and grapefruit pith with a touch of lemony citrus. Considering how aromatic the wine was, it was a bit of a letdown on the palate as that exuberance didn't really carry over. The alcohol was very high here again (14%) and was much more obvious and in the way than on the previous bottle. All in all, this reminded me more of a Sancerre style Sauvignon Blanc than a Riesling which makes me wonder whether these grapes were a little underripe or whether they may something else blended in here (the DOC regulations stipulate that if a varietal is stated, the wine only needs to be comprised of 85 - 100% of that varietal with the rest made up of "other local similar varietals"). My money's on slightly underripe grapes, for what it's worth, and I would consider pairing this the same way I would the wine above, really, as it still had the big body with the lackluster acidity.
All in all, Kerner probably isn't going to replace Riesling any time soon, but it is a refreshing change of pace. I'd recommend drinking these wines young and pairing them with fairly hefty dishes that aren't particularly acidic. Also, because of the body and the high alcohol content, these feel more like autumn or winter weather whites to me, as they're not all that refreshing to drink on their own. Alto Adige has plenty of light zippy wines that will serve you better for the warm months ahead.
Monday, March 28, 2011
Schiava - Alto Adige, Italy
I'd like to start this post out with a public service announcement: if you have Google's safe search turned off, I do not recommend doing an image search for Schiava if you are at your place of employment or in any other public setting. You should probably make sure you search for "schiava grape" or "schiava wine" unless you want to get quite a surprise.With that out of the way, we can now focus on today's wine. When we think about other countries, it's too easy to fall into the trap of thinking of whole countries as a single undifferentiated monoculture. With Italy, for example, it's easy to think that the whole country eats the same kinds of foods or even speaks the exact same language within its borders. For the US readers who aren't totally with me yet, think about how different the cultures of Georgia and Massachusetts are (a cultural divide that I've lived and experienced, being originally from Georgia and currently located in Massachusetts). One of the great things that has happened in writing this blog is that I've been able to look at smaller regions and see the differences in these regions compared to other regions within the same country. Some of the most interesting regions are those that are on a country's borderline, like Alsace in France. There is often an interesting mix of two cultures in these geographical regions that borrows some from each, but is individually distinct from both.
The Alto Adige region of Italy is one of these border territories. Located in the northeastern corner of Italy, Alto Adige constitutes the northern half of the Trentino-Alto Adige zone and is the most northerly section of Italy. It is a mountainous region (it is estimated that only about 15% of the land here is suitable for agriculture of any kind) that shares a border with Austria and Switzerland. Historically, the region was a part of Austria-Hungary and that empire's predecessors, but the region was annexed by Italy following World War I. The culture here is very Germanic and the region has two official languages: German and Italian. On wine labels, you are as likely to see "Alto Adige" as the region as you are to see its Germanic name, Südtirol, which means "South Tyrol," so named because the southern part of the Tyrol river flows through here.
Most production in this region today is focused on white wines, though at one point in time Schiava was by far the most widely grown grape in Alto Adige, accounting for 60% of the region's production, though that number has shrunk considerably in the more recent past. There are some other interesting native red grapes that can be difficult to find in the US. Lagrein and Teroldego are grown here and they will be the focus of a future post, but today's wines are made from Schiava, aka Trollinger, aka Vernatsch. Schiava has been grown in Alto Adige since the 15th Century and in Württemberg, Germany since the 17th Century. It is eaten as a table grape in Great Britain under the name Black Hamburg. It is a vigorous and hardy grape that must be aggressively pruned and managed in the vineyard to prevent out of control yields. The grape is thin-skinned and not particularly powerful in the first place so overcropping can have serious deleterious effects. The wines produced from Schiava are rarely imported into the US because even at their densest, they tend to be light in color and extract and resemble hearty rosés rather than the full bodied red wines that are currently in such fashion in here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




