There are some grapes and wines out there that there just isn't a lot of information on. Today's grape seems to be one of those. The Oxford Companion to Wine has a whopping three sentences about Piedirosso and there isn't much other information available online. Most of the information that I have is from Nicolas Belfrage's Brunello to Zibibbo: The Wines of Tuscany, Central and Southern Italy which is the second volume of his incredible two-volume publication on the wines of Italy. I like Belfrage's approach because he focuses a lot on the grapes of Italy while still keeping the geographical approach that is so necessary to understanding the Italian wine landscape. This two-volume set along with Bastianich and Lynch's Vino Italiano give the interested reader an excellent foothold in the world of Italian wines.
So on to Piedirosso. Those of you with a bit of familiarity with the Italian language can suss out what the name of the grape means, but for the rest of you, it means "red feet." Regular readers may remember a post a few weeks back about a grape called Refosco dal Pedunculo Rosso which has a similar name. In both cases, the red feet refer to the stems which have a reddish color to them. Piedirosso is also known as Palombina or Per'e Palummo which means "little dove" and "dove's foot" in the local dialect because the stem is made of up of three branches that can resemble a bird's foot. Since Piedirosso and Refosco share the red-stemmed characteristic, it's natural to think they may be related in some way, but I can't seem to find any evidence to support that claim. Belfrage claims that both grapes belong to the Malbec family (his claim being tempered by an admission that it is through hearsay only) but again, I can't find any corroboration for that.
The grape itself is purported to be of ancient origin and is thought to be the same as the Colombina mentioned by the Roman author Pliny. It reached the peak of its popularity towards the end of the 19th Century as it was very heavily replanted into the phylloxera ravaged vineyard areas of southern Italy. At its peak, Piedirosso was planted on about 10,000 hectares of land. In 1844, an Italian writer said that wines made from Piedirosso were not only the equal in finesse of those made from Aglianico grapes, but they were superior in terms of power. That opinion didn't hold, though, and as of 1990, there were only about 1,000 hectares of land devoted to its cultivation. Plantings seem to have increased over the past twenty years, but the grape is hardly in any danger of catching the world on fire anytime soon. Today it is used mostly as a blending grape in southern Italy, but there are a few producers who make 100% varietal wines.
The wine that I was able to pick up was the 2008 Mustilli bottling from the Sannio DOC in Campania. I picked this bottle up at Federal Wine and Spirits for about $18. In the glass, the wine had a medium purple-ruby color. The nose was nicely aromatic with fresh blackberry, brambly wild berry fruit, chocolate, a touch of stewed blueberry and some cassis. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with high acidity and low tannins. There were flavors of sour cherry and brambly berry fruit along with some blackcurrant, licorice and baking chocolate with just a touch of funk. There was a very nice balance here between the fruit flavors and the earthy chocolate and licorice notes. The acidity is definitely up there with this wine, making it a very nice, versatile wine to have with food. These high-acid, soft tannin red wines from Italy always make me think about tomato sauce and that seems as good a pairing as any. I'm definitely a sucker for these high-acid reds with wild, almost savage fruit in them and this wine was definitely right up my alley.
A blog devoted to exploring wines made from unusual grape varieties and/or grown in unfamiliar regions all over the world. All wines are purchased by me from shops in the Boston metro area or directly from wineries that I have visited. If a reviewed bottle is a free sample, that fact is acknowledged prior to the bottle's review. I do not receive any compensation from any of the wineries, wine shops or companies that I mention on the blog.
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Friday, August 26, 2011
Himrod and Lakemont - Finger Lakes, New York
![]() | |
| Himrod Grape Cluster |
Someone may already be asking the question "well, those grapes aren't very expensive, why don't I just go ahead and give that a shot?" The short answer is: seedless table grapes tend to make lousy wine. The long answer is essentially the same, but with much more detail. If you've read the site more than once, you'll know that I don't like short answers, so buckle up, because here we go.
First we need to consider where seedless grapes come from and why they are the way they are. Seedless fruit is not a naturally occurring phenomenon since, for a plant, the seed inside the fruit is the natural way for the plant to propogate itself. Seedless fruit is typically bred by humans as a convenience for consumers. Many people aren't very comfortable with the process of spitting things out and for fruit like watermelon or grapes, there isn't really any clean, comfortable way to eat around the seeds. Further, if you offer people the choice between food that is messy and a lot of work to eat or fruit that is easy to just pop in your mouth, they'll choose the path of least resistance almost every time.
Grapes have a kind of double whammy of trouble, though. Not only are the seeds inedible and an inconvenience to eat around, but the skins are also very thick and often inedible, so the grape must be eaten either by popping the pulp out of the skins directly into the mouth (and then spitting out the seeds) or by eating the whole grape and spitting the skin and seeds out together. Finicky eaters are not fond of either option and when you add to all that the fact that many grapes have high levels of tannins in their skins (and seeds) which are very bitter and can cause an astringent sensation in the mouth, well, you're starting to see the many different reasons some people may have for deciding not to eat grapes at all.
![]() | |
| Lakemont Grape Bunches |
And so on, etc. But Mr. Pitchman, we may ask, if these grapes are so amazing then why aren't more wines made from them? And why is it that the wines that are made from them aren't very exciting? There are a few answers. First of all, the skins on the seedless grapes are so thin that they don't impart much flavor to the wine. This isn't a big deal in white wine making where there is minimal skin contact anyway, but it's a huge deal-breaker for red wine production. The main reason, though, is that the grapes themselves just don't taste like very much. There are a number of possible reasons for this. First of all, it may just be that the bland flavor of seedless grapes is what appeals to the largest cross-section of consumers and is thus what sells the best. It's also likely that whatever flavors the grapes may have is diluted due to the fact that they are designed and employed to produce massive amounts of grapes per vine. Take another look at that Himrod cluster at the top of the page. The clusters are enormous and the goal of the grower is always to get as many of those clusters as possible from the vines since tonnage is all that matters. Deep, explosive flavors are irrelevant in table grape production. You just want as many bunches as possible.
All of which brings us to the two grapes that this particular wine is made from. The first is Himrod, which was developed and then released in 1952 by the New York Agricultural Experiment Station in Geneva, New York, which is located at the northern tip of Seneca Lake. The second grape is Lakemont, which was released in 1972 from the same institution. Both grapes are hybrids and are siblings of one another, which means that the parentage for each is identical (there are two other grapes that are the result of this same parentage: Interlaken and Romulus). In all cases, the two parents are Ontario, itself a crossing (or possibly a hybrid as I'm not sure about the exact species designation of the two parents) between Winchell and Diamond, and Thompson Seedless, which I did not realize was actually a vinifera grape until today (it is native to either Turkey, Greece or Iran). All four of the sibling grapes are named for towns in the Finger Lakes region.
The wine that I bought was from Fulkerson Winery on Seneca Lake. The wine is named "Matinee" and is made up of Himrod and Lakemont grapes in some unknown proportion. The bottle cost $14 at the winery. In the glass, the wine had a pale, silvery lemon color. The nose was moderately open with aromas of mint and green melon. The mint is startlingly prominent here as my note indicates that the aroma is "like toothpaste." On the palate, the wine had a light-medium body with medium acidity and was definitely sweet. There were flavors of tangerine and mandarin orange along with mint, candy apple and candied lime citrus. It definitely had a bit more complexity than I was expecting, but let's be honest, this isn't a "serious" wine by any stretch of the imagination. That doesn't make it a bad wine, though. Wines like this have their place and don't necessarily deserve to be looked down on just because they're sweet and unabashedly unpretentious. There are times in my life when I want crème brûlée for dessert and there are other times when I just want gummy bears. This is a gummy bear wine for those days when you want something sweet and a little fun and don't want to spend a lot of time thinking about what's in your glass. It's respectable for what it is and while it's not a style I reach for often, it's out there for those who want to seek it out.
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Petit Rouge - Enfer d'Arvier, Valle d'Aosta, Italy
Today marks Fringe Wine's first foray into the wild and wonderful Valle d'Aosta, the smallest region of Italy. What the region lacks in size it more than makes up for in its wide array of native grape varietals, though. While you may see familiar northern Italian names like Nebbiolo and Dolcetto or familiar French names like Gamay and Pinot Noir on the lists of approved varietals for DOC level wines, you're much more likely to see things like Premetta, Cornalin, Prié Blanc, Fumin, or today's grape, Petit Rouge, just to name a few. The Institut Agricole Régional, a local agricultural school (who also makes wine), has identified thirteen indigenous varieties in the Valle d'Aosta. The region is positively tantalizing for me and should, in theory, provide me with a ton of material to write about on a regular basis except for one thing: the wines from the Valle d'Aosta are really hard to find.
Out of the 20 regions of Italy, the Valle d'Aosta ranks dead last both in vineyard area and total production (though they are seventh in percentage of of DOC wines as about 26% of all production in the region is at the DOC level). As of 2000, the region had just over 500 hectares of land under vine and produced about 27,000 hectoliters of wine, which is enough to make about 300,000 cases of wine. By contrast, Piemonte, one region over to the east, produces nearly 3 million hectoliters of wine, and that amount is only good for seventh highest in Italy (first place belongs to the Veneto with a whopping 8.8 million hectoliters produced). E&J Gallo, the largest wine company in the USA, has an annual sales total of 76 million cases, meaning that this single company sells more than 250 times more wine than is produced in all of the Valle d'Aosta each year.
The point being, very little wine is produced here. To compound matters, the region is a tourist hotspot, as it is located in the Alps on the border with France and Switzerland. Lots of tourists means lots of demand for local wine so very little of the already miniscule country makes it out of the Valle d'Aosta even to other regions of Italy, much less to places farther afield than that. While it's certainly not easy to track some of these wines down, it's by no means impossible and I've managed over the past year to stockpile quite a few interesting bottles from this region which I hope to be able to write about over the next few months.
The first grape I want to consider is the most planted native red grape in the region, Petit Rouge. Somewhat surprisingly given its high altitude, almost 90% of production in the Valle d'Aosta is red wine and Petit Rouge plays a fairly large role in red wines throughout the region. The grape is thought to be native to the Valle d'Aosta, though it also may or may not be the same grape as Rouge de Valais in Switzerland, which is probably not a big deal to most people as you're not likely to trip over many Rouge de Valais wines in your lifetime. The variety ripens fairly late and the berries can have a dusty, gray appearance on the vine.
The bottle that I picked up is from a sub-zone within the Valle d'Aosta called Enfer d'Arvier which is apparently a whopping 5 hectares in total. The winegrowing areas of the Valle d'Aosta are in the valley of the Dora Baltea river as it flows down through the Alps and into the Po River. The town of Arvier is on the western end of the valley and apparently it can get pretty warm there as the name Enfer d'Arvier suggests (it means literally "Hell of Arvier). The DOC regulations for this area dictate a minimum of 85% Petit Rouge, but this particular wine clocks in at 100%. The producer is Danilo Thomain who farms about one hectare of land in this region and is the only independent producer in the area (everything else is vinified and bottled by co-ops). His total production is a miniscule 2400 bottles per year. I was able to find the 2008 bottling of his Enfer d'Arvier for $35 from my friends at the Wine Bottega.
In the glass, this wine had medium saturation and was a nice ruby color. The nose was very aromatic with plummy fruit, wet leather, and stewed berries with a bit of sweaty funk to it. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with no tannins but surprisingly high acidity. This grape typically isn't very acidic when fully ripe, but given the relatively light color (the grape can be very dark and is frequently used in blends to deepen the color of the finished wine), it may have been picked early enough to keep some of that acidity around. There were tart red cherry and wild raspberry fruit flavors with a bit of bitter funkiness on the end. It may have had just a touch of residual effervescence to it...I wasn't able to make up my mind for sure one way or the other. It definitely had a kind of prickly sensation in the mouth that made me think there may be a little CO2 running loose in there. Overall, it was a nice, tart and zingy red wine with bright juicy berry fruit and a touch of red plum. On day two it started to pick up some grape soda flavors, odd enough. This was a very cool, very different kind of wine. If you have a zero tolerance policy on funk in wine, this won't do it for you, but I thought that it was mild enough and well-integrated enough to add something interesting rather than completely taking over. The acid here makes it great for a wide variety of foods and the wine itself is light enough that it won't dominate more delicate meat dishes. If you can find a bottle of this, it's definitely worth your time, especially since you might not get another chance to try it given the production numbers.
Out of the 20 regions of Italy, the Valle d'Aosta ranks dead last both in vineyard area and total production (though they are seventh in percentage of of DOC wines as about 26% of all production in the region is at the DOC level). As of 2000, the region had just over 500 hectares of land under vine and produced about 27,000 hectoliters of wine, which is enough to make about 300,000 cases of wine. By contrast, Piemonte, one region over to the east, produces nearly 3 million hectoliters of wine, and that amount is only good for seventh highest in Italy (first place belongs to the Veneto with a whopping 8.8 million hectoliters produced). E&J Gallo, the largest wine company in the USA, has an annual sales total of 76 million cases, meaning that this single company sells more than 250 times more wine than is produced in all of the Valle d'Aosta each year.
The point being, very little wine is produced here. To compound matters, the region is a tourist hotspot, as it is located in the Alps on the border with France and Switzerland. Lots of tourists means lots of demand for local wine so very little of the already miniscule country makes it out of the Valle d'Aosta even to other regions of Italy, much less to places farther afield than that. While it's certainly not easy to track some of these wines down, it's by no means impossible and I've managed over the past year to stockpile quite a few interesting bottles from this region which I hope to be able to write about over the next few months.
The first grape I want to consider is the most planted native red grape in the region, Petit Rouge. Somewhat surprisingly given its high altitude, almost 90% of production in the Valle d'Aosta is red wine and Petit Rouge plays a fairly large role in red wines throughout the region. The grape is thought to be native to the Valle d'Aosta, though it also may or may not be the same grape as Rouge de Valais in Switzerland, which is probably not a big deal to most people as you're not likely to trip over many Rouge de Valais wines in your lifetime. The variety ripens fairly late and the berries can have a dusty, gray appearance on the vine.
The bottle that I picked up is from a sub-zone within the Valle d'Aosta called Enfer d'Arvier which is apparently a whopping 5 hectares in total. The winegrowing areas of the Valle d'Aosta are in the valley of the Dora Baltea river as it flows down through the Alps and into the Po River. The town of Arvier is on the western end of the valley and apparently it can get pretty warm there as the name Enfer d'Arvier suggests (it means literally "Hell of Arvier). The DOC regulations for this area dictate a minimum of 85% Petit Rouge, but this particular wine clocks in at 100%. The producer is Danilo Thomain who farms about one hectare of land in this region and is the only independent producer in the area (everything else is vinified and bottled by co-ops). His total production is a miniscule 2400 bottles per year. I was able to find the 2008 bottling of his Enfer d'Arvier for $35 from my friends at the Wine Bottega.
In the glass, this wine had medium saturation and was a nice ruby color. The nose was very aromatic with plummy fruit, wet leather, and stewed berries with a bit of sweaty funk to it. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with no tannins but surprisingly high acidity. This grape typically isn't very acidic when fully ripe, but given the relatively light color (the grape can be very dark and is frequently used in blends to deepen the color of the finished wine), it may have been picked early enough to keep some of that acidity around. There were tart red cherry and wild raspberry fruit flavors with a bit of bitter funkiness on the end. It may have had just a touch of residual effervescence to it...I wasn't able to make up my mind for sure one way or the other. It definitely had a kind of prickly sensation in the mouth that made me think there may be a little CO2 running loose in there. Overall, it was a nice, tart and zingy red wine with bright juicy berry fruit and a touch of red plum. On day two it started to pick up some grape soda flavors, odd enough. This was a very cool, very different kind of wine. If you have a zero tolerance policy on funk in wine, this won't do it for you, but I thought that it was mild enough and well-integrated enough to add something interesting rather than completely taking over. The acid here makes it great for a wide variety of foods and the wine itself is light enough that it won't dominate more delicate meat dishes. If you can find a bottle of this, it's definitely worth your time, especially since you might not get another chance to try it given the production numbers.
Monday, August 22, 2011
Ribolla Gialla (Robola) - Friuli-Venezia, Italy and Cephalonia, Greece
Ribolla Gialla has many different homes but can still be difficult to locate. I was somehow able to find three different bottles of Ribolla, all of which were from three different countries. Oddly enough, those were the only three bottles of Ribolla I was able to find. It's very rare for me to find an unusual grape variety with that kind of limited availability but with that kind of geographical distribution. That's how it worked out, though, and now that I've pulled the cork on all three bottles, I'm here to tell you what I know about the grape.
It is thought that Ribolla Gialla (so called to differentiate it from Ribolla Verde, an inferior mutation of the grape) originally came from Greece and arrived in northeastern Italy by way of Slovenia. It's not a coincidence then that the three bottles I was able to find were from Greece, Italy and Slovenia. Today it is most well established in the Friuli-Venezia region of northeastern Italy and the recorded history of the grape really begins at some point after its introduction to this region. In 1289 the grape is mentioned for the first time in a vineyard land contract and in 1402, the city of Udine passed a law making it illegal to adulterate wine made from the Ribolla grape. In the 14th Century, the grape makes its literary debut as Giovanni Boccaccio lists indulgence of Ribolla wines as a sin of gluttony in one of his works, and, several centuries later, Italian writer Antonio Musnig lists Ribolla as the finest wine made in Friuli.
Life was good for the grape up until the 19th Century when phylloxera hit. Like so many regions across Europe, Friuli-Venezia was hit hard by phylloxera and the vineyards were decimated by the louse. And as in so many other regions, after phylloxera was contained, when the locals decided to replant their vineyards, many of them opted to plant grapes other than the ones that had such historical success in the region. Friuli in particular looked to France for their grape varieties and much of the land was replanted to Merlot, Sauvignon Blanc and Pinot Gris (subsequently Italianized to Pinot Grigio). By the 1990's, fewer than one percent of DOC level wines in Friuli contained any Ribolla at all.
The grape has rebounded somewhat in the past decade or so, though it still is not widely planted. Bastianich and Lynch lump the grape in the "others" section of the "Key Grapes" part of their profile of Friuli in Vino Italiano. In Slovenia, where it is known as Rebula, the grape is limited mostly to the Goriška Brda region of Primorska which is essentially the eastern extension of the Collio region of Italy into Slovenian land. In Greece, where the grape is called Robola, it is grown almost exclusively on the island of Cephalonia off the western coast of the country. Interestingly, most resources on Greek wine don't indicate that their Robola is the same as Italy's Ribolla, though they are almost certainly one and the same.
**UPDATE**
After doing a little more research on Greek Robola, it turns out that the case may be much less clear than Jancis Robinson & Co. indicate in The Oxford Companion to Wine. In his excellent book The Wines of Greece, Konstantinos Lazarakis mentions that Robola may be a catch-all term for many different white grapes that aren't necessarily related to one another, in much the same way as Vernacchia is used in Italy to represent a host of different grapes in different regions. One genetic study in California found that the Robola they tested was genetically identical to a grape called Thiako. A similar study in Athens found that the Robola they tested was actually the Goustolidi grape, which is completely different from and totally unrelated to the Thiaka grape. Further, there are distinctive amepelographical differences between Ribolla Gialla and the Robola found in Greek vineyards that would indicate that they are two (or three or four) different grapes. Without any definitive DNA testing, it's hard to say at this point, but hopefully future research will clarify the issue.
*********
As mentioned at the very top, I picked up three wines for this post, but only two were really worth remarking on. The third was a 2000 Movia Ribolla from Slovenia. The color gave this wine away really before I even tried to taste it. It was a deep amber gold which you can see in the photo at right. I don't usually take pictures of the wine in the glass, but this color was so remarkable I felt I should try to show it. The nose was totally shot as well with a little nutty aroma and some butterscotch but mostly it was just a total blank. I drank a few glasses of it anyway because I paid $25 for the bottle and figured I'd give it a shot. The fruit was completely gone and there was just a hint of nuttiness left here. If you were in an especially charitable mood, I guess you could describe it as minerally but in reality it was just an old bottle that should have been pulled from the shelf years ago.
The next wine that I tried was a 2009 Volpe Passini Ribolla Gialla from the Delle Venezie IGT which I picked up for about $18. In the glass, the wine had a medium lemon color and a shy nose. There was a little bit of peachy fruit, but this was another total blank. I was starting to wonder at this point if the other wine was really shot or if this grape just didn't have much character. On the palate the wine was on the lighter side of medium with fairly high acidity. Again, the palate was pretty flavor neutral with some lemony notes and citrus peel flavors and a little bit of nuttiness that reminded me of hazelnuts. The wine had a nice, clean minerally finish to it. All in all, I can't say that this wine really appealed to me that much. There was definitely a clear difference between this wine and the one that was obviously over the hill, but they were actually closer to one another than I would have liked to see. "Mostly neutral" is my sum-up note and I guess I'll stick with that.
Never one to give up on a grape before giving it every chance to win me over, the next wine that I tried was a 2009 Gentilini Robola from Cephalonia, Greece, which I picked up from my friends at the Wine Bottega for about $20. In the glass, the wine was a pale silvery lemon color with some green tints to it. The nose was fairly open with grapefruit and lemon peel aromas with a whiff of stone fruit lurking the backgroun. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with fairly high acidity. There was a lot of nice lemon-lime fruit with some citrus peel and a clean finish. This wasn't terrifically complicated, but it did what it did very nicely. The light lemony fruit was really carried by the snappy acidity and the minerally backbone. Of the three wines that I tried, this was the hands-down winner and was the only one of the three that I would consider buying again. This strikes me as a seafood kind of wine that wouldn't be too out of place with white-meat chicken dishes as well. It's subtle and acidic enough to also make a very nice aperitif or a wine to just enjoy on a hot day.
It is thought that Ribolla Gialla (so called to differentiate it from Ribolla Verde, an inferior mutation of the grape) originally came from Greece and arrived in northeastern Italy by way of Slovenia. It's not a coincidence then that the three bottles I was able to find were from Greece, Italy and Slovenia. Today it is most well established in the Friuli-Venezia region of northeastern Italy and the recorded history of the grape really begins at some point after its introduction to this region. In 1289 the grape is mentioned for the first time in a vineyard land contract and in 1402, the city of Udine passed a law making it illegal to adulterate wine made from the Ribolla grape. In the 14th Century, the grape makes its literary debut as Giovanni Boccaccio lists indulgence of Ribolla wines as a sin of gluttony in one of his works, and, several centuries later, Italian writer Antonio Musnig lists Ribolla as the finest wine made in Friuli.
Life was good for the grape up until the 19th Century when phylloxera hit. Like so many regions across Europe, Friuli-Venezia was hit hard by phylloxera and the vineyards were decimated by the louse. And as in so many other regions, after phylloxera was contained, when the locals decided to replant their vineyards, many of them opted to plant grapes other than the ones that had such historical success in the region. Friuli in particular looked to France for their grape varieties and much of the land was replanted to Merlot, Sauvignon Blanc and Pinot Gris (subsequently Italianized to Pinot Grigio). By the 1990's, fewer than one percent of DOC level wines in Friuli contained any Ribolla at all.
The grape has rebounded somewhat in the past decade or so, though it still is not widely planted. Bastianich and Lynch lump the grape in the "others" section of the "Key Grapes" part of their profile of Friuli in Vino Italiano. In Slovenia, where it is known as Rebula, the grape is limited mostly to the Goriška Brda region of Primorska which is essentially the eastern extension of the Collio region of Italy into Slovenian land. In Greece, where the grape is called Robola, it is grown almost exclusively on the island of Cephalonia off the western coast of the country. Interestingly, most resources on Greek wine don't indicate that their Robola is the same as Italy's Ribolla, though they are almost certainly one and the same.
**UPDATE**
After doing a little more research on Greek Robola, it turns out that the case may be much less clear than Jancis Robinson & Co. indicate in The Oxford Companion to Wine. In his excellent book The Wines of Greece, Konstantinos Lazarakis mentions that Robola may be a catch-all term for many different white grapes that aren't necessarily related to one another, in much the same way as Vernacchia is used in Italy to represent a host of different grapes in different regions. One genetic study in California found that the Robola they tested was genetically identical to a grape called Thiako. A similar study in Athens found that the Robola they tested was actually the Goustolidi grape, which is completely different from and totally unrelated to the Thiaka grape. Further, there are distinctive amepelographical differences between Ribolla Gialla and the Robola found in Greek vineyards that would indicate that they are two (or three or four) different grapes. Without any definitive DNA testing, it's hard to say at this point, but hopefully future research will clarify the issue.
*********
As mentioned at the very top, I picked up three wines for this post, but only two were really worth remarking on. The third was a 2000 Movia Ribolla from Slovenia. The color gave this wine away really before I even tried to taste it. It was a deep amber gold which you can see in the photo at right. I don't usually take pictures of the wine in the glass, but this color was so remarkable I felt I should try to show it. The nose was totally shot as well with a little nutty aroma and some butterscotch but mostly it was just a total blank. I drank a few glasses of it anyway because I paid $25 for the bottle and figured I'd give it a shot. The fruit was completely gone and there was just a hint of nuttiness left here. If you were in an especially charitable mood, I guess you could describe it as minerally but in reality it was just an old bottle that should have been pulled from the shelf years ago.
The next wine that I tried was a 2009 Volpe Passini Ribolla Gialla from the Delle Venezie IGT which I picked up for about $18. In the glass, the wine had a medium lemon color and a shy nose. There was a little bit of peachy fruit, but this was another total blank. I was starting to wonder at this point if the other wine was really shot or if this grape just didn't have much character. On the palate the wine was on the lighter side of medium with fairly high acidity. Again, the palate was pretty flavor neutral with some lemony notes and citrus peel flavors and a little bit of nuttiness that reminded me of hazelnuts. The wine had a nice, clean minerally finish to it. All in all, I can't say that this wine really appealed to me that much. There was definitely a clear difference between this wine and the one that was obviously over the hill, but they were actually closer to one another than I would have liked to see. "Mostly neutral" is my sum-up note and I guess I'll stick with that.
Never one to give up on a grape before giving it every chance to win me over, the next wine that I tried was a 2009 Gentilini Robola from Cephalonia, Greece, which I picked up from my friends at the Wine Bottega for about $20. In the glass, the wine was a pale silvery lemon color with some green tints to it. The nose was fairly open with grapefruit and lemon peel aromas with a whiff of stone fruit lurking the backgroun. On the palate, the wine was medium bodied with fairly high acidity. There was a lot of nice lemon-lime fruit with some citrus peel and a clean finish. This wasn't terrifically complicated, but it did what it did very nicely. The light lemony fruit was really carried by the snappy acidity and the minerally backbone. Of the three wines that I tried, this was the hands-down winner and was the only one of the three that I would consider buying again. This strikes me as a seafood kind of wine that wouldn't be too out of place with white-meat chicken dishes as well. It's subtle and acidic enough to also make a very nice aperitif or a wine to just enjoy on a hot day.
Labels:
Cephalonia,
Friuli,
Greece,
Italy,
Ribolla Gialla,
Robola,
Slovenia,
White Wine
Friday, August 19, 2011
Blanc de Franc (White Cabernet Franc) - Chinon, Loire Valley, France
If I only gave you two out of the three pertinent pieces of information about today's wine, you would rightfully be wondering what on earth I was doing writing about it. If I told you, for instance, that today I was writing about a wine made from the Cabernet Franc grape from the Chinon region of the Loire Valley, you might think that I had finally abandoned the conceit of this website and decided to just write about any old thing that ended up in my glass. Well, I haven't, and today's wine, while made from a very well known grape in a very well known region, is one of the more unusual wines I've ever tried. It's a white wine made from the red Cabernet Franc grape.
How is that possible? Well, for those of you unfamiliar with grape physiology, the fleshy pulp in the middle of a grape is almost always white and, when pressed, will give white juice. To make a red wine, you need for the juice to be in contact with the skins of the grape for an extended period of time so that the pigments in the skins can be leeched out into the juice. There are a few grapes that have red pulp in the middle, but they're fairly rare. They're called teinturier grapes and there are only a few species that are used to make wines (Alicante Bouschet is probably the most common and Saperavi is the only one that we've covered on this blog).
So to make a white wine from red grapes, all you really need to do is press the grapes gently and do everything possible to minimize the amount of time that the juice spends in contact with the skins. This is common practice in many areas where sparkling wine is made as two of the three most common sparkling wine grapes are actually red grapes (Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier). But in still wine production, it's a very rare thing indeed. The only other examples I have ever seen have been German Pinot Noir wines that were made into white wines (I hope to be able to write about a few of those in the future).
There are probably a lot of reasons that we don't typically see white wines made from red grapes. Red wines, as a general rule, tend to command higher prices than white wines, so it makes more sense for people with red grapes to go ahead and make red wines. The skins of red wines are also loaded with compounds that add a great deal of complexity to a finished wine and many winemakers are probably very uncomfortable with throwing away anything that can add character and complexity to their wines. Finally, there are white skinned grapes that make white wines, so why would you bother to try and do the same kind of thing with a grape with a red skin?
For winemakers in sparkling wine regions and for those making white wines from Pinot Noir in Germany, the reason is probably because their climate is so cool that they have a very hard time getting those dark-skinned grapes to ripen fully. Under-ripe red grapes tend to have weedy, vegetal flavors and tough, unpleasant tannins that become more pronounced if the juice spends a lot of time in contact with the skins. These growers get around that by just jettisoning the skins and making wine from the white juice that is pressed out.
Which is all well and good for those growers, but why would someone want to do that with a grape like Cabernet Franc in an area like Chinon in the Loire Valley where the grape usually thrives? To be honest, I don't have a clue. It could be that they made a selection of grapes that weren't ripe enough to make it into one of their red cuveés and decided to make a white wine from those as an experiment. The most likely explanation is that they just decided they wanted to try it and went for it. It's hard to say, especially because the wine itself isn't listed on the producer's website at all. All I can say for sure is that someone decided to give it a shot and I was able to taste the results.
The producer in question is Couly-Dutheil, a well-established estate in the Chinon region of the Loire Valley. The bottle itself is technically a non-vintage bottling and technically we aren't supposed to know what grape it was made from. The AOC laws do not recognize white wines made from Cabernet Franc grapes in this region, so the only category available for this to be bottled as was vin de table which, by law, is prohibited from mentioning any regions, grapes, or vintages. Proprietary names are allowed on the bottle, though, so the house decided to call this "Blanc de Franc," which is technically still legal since it doesn't mention the full name of the grape on the label though it gives us a huge clue as to what's inside the bottle. As for the region, since we know where the producer is located, it's easy for us to fill that blank in as well. The vintage is usually indicated in some kind of code somewhere on the bottle, but I didn't spend a lot of time searching for it. Other online sources that have reviewed this wine all seem to have a 2008 bottling, so there's a good chance that this is from that vintage as well. I've read on a few of those that only about 25 cases of this wine made it into the US, so good luck trying to find a bottle for yourself.
The bottle I picked up cost $29 from Cardullo's in Harvard Square. In the glass, the wine was a pale, silvery lemon color. The nose was very aromatic and puzzling. It had aromas of raspberries and peaches with some ripe apple and something like pie dough mixed in. It's a disconcerting feeling to look at a glass of white wine and smell red fruits in it, but that's what was happening here. On the palate the wine was medium bodied with medium acidity. There was light raspberry and apple fruit with a biscuitty, pastry dough kind of character to it. If you had blindfolded me and had me try this wine, I probably would have sworn it was a rosé or a very light bodied red wine. It was probably more interesting than it was good, but it was still a very cool wine to try.
How is that possible? Well, for those of you unfamiliar with grape physiology, the fleshy pulp in the middle of a grape is almost always white and, when pressed, will give white juice. To make a red wine, you need for the juice to be in contact with the skins of the grape for an extended period of time so that the pigments in the skins can be leeched out into the juice. There are a few grapes that have red pulp in the middle, but they're fairly rare. They're called teinturier grapes and there are only a few species that are used to make wines (Alicante Bouschet is probably the most common and Saperavi is the only one that we've covered on this blog).
So to make a white wine from red grapes, all you really need to do is press the grapes gently and do everything possible to minimize the amount of time that the juice spends in contact with the skins. This is common practice in many areas where sparkling wine is made as two of the three most common sparkling wine grapes are actually red grapes (Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier). But in still wine production, it's a very rare thing indeed. The only other examples I have ever seen have been German Pinot Noir wines that were made into white wines (I hope to be able to write about a few of those in the future).
There are probably a lot of reasons that we don't typically see white wines made from red grapes. Red wines, as a general rule, tend to command higher prices than white wines, so it makes more sense for people with red grapes to go ahead and make red wines. The skins of red wines are also loaded with compounds that add a great deal of complexity to a finished wine and many winemakers are probably very uncomfortable with throwing away anything that can add character and complexity to their wines. Finally, there are white skinned grapes that make white wines, so why would you bother to try and do the same kind of thing with a grape with a red skin?
For winemakers in sparkling wine regions and for those making white wines from Pinot Noir in Germany, the reason is probably because their climate is so cool that they have a very hard time getting those dark-skinned grapes to ripen fully. Under-ripe red grapes tend to have weedy, vegetal flavors and tough, unpleasant tannins that become more pronounced if the juice spends a lot of time in contact with the skins. These growers get around that by just jettisoning the skins and making wine from the white juice that is pressed out.
Which is all well and good for those growers, but why would someone want to do that with a grape like Cabernet Franc in an area like Chinon in the Loire Valley where the grape usually thrives? To be honest, I don't have a clue. It could be that they made a selection of grapes that weren't ripe enough to make it into one of their red cuveés and decided to make a white wine from those as an experiment. The most likely explanation is that they just decided they wanted to try it and went for it. It's hard to say, especially because the wine itself isn't listed on the producer's website at all. All I can say for sure is that someone decided to give it a shot and I was able to taste the results.
The bottle I picked up cost $29 from Cardullo's in Harvard Square. In the glass, the wine was a pale, silvery lemon color. The nose was very aromatic and puzzling. It had aromas of raspberries and peaches with some ripe apple and something like pie dough mixed in. It's a disconcerting feeling to look at a glass of white wine and smell red fruits in it, but that's what was happening here. On the palate the wine was medium bodied with medium acidity. There was light raspberry and apple fruit with a biscuitty, pastry dough kind of character to it. If you had blindfolded me and had me try this wine, I probably would have sworn it was a rosé or a very light bodied red wine. It was probably more interesting than it was good, but it was still a very cool wine to try.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





